Developers to resubmit proposals for student accommodation after council refuses plans over legal issues
Developers behind a proposed student accommodation scheme in Sunderland have pledged to resubmit proposals, after initial plans were refused by council development chiefs over issues with a legal agreement.
Sunderland City Council’s planning department has blocked an application for 60 - 66 John Street in the city centre, opposite the former Joplings building, after considering it for more than a year.
Estate agent and property developer Ashbrookes recently opened a branch in part of the former job centre building’s ground floor and last year (2024), plans were submitted to develop the rest of the site.
.jpeg?crop=3:2,smart&trim=&width=640&quality=65)

This included “an off-site financial contribution to mitigate the increased recreational pressure upon the protected coastline” and a “further condition relating to the construction environment management plan for the development.”
However, a committee report from council planning officers, presented to the Planning and Highways Committee on July 21, 2025, confirmed the legal agreement linked to the development had not been completed.
The council report noted that there “had not been any substantive progress on the legal agreement” since April, 2025, particularly around the requested financial contribution, and noted the council had made repeated attempts to contact the applicant.
Legal agreements are a standard process used by council planning departments to secure financial contributions from developers, with cash earmarked to improve infrastructure and local facilities in many cases, as well as funding work to reduce the 'recreational impact' of new homes on local nature sites.
In a decision notice published on September 4, 2025, Sunderland City Council's planning department refused the John Street plans with an "officer memo" from council planners outlining the reasons.
This included the absence of an "off-site financial contribution to mitigate the increased recreational pressure upon the protected coastline" and as a result of the legal agreement not being completed, the plans were refused.
It was noted that "there does not exist a mechanism to provide the relevant obligations which make the proposed development acceptable in planning terms."
Arif Mushtaq, of Ashbrookes Group, described the circumstances around the council refusal decision as a "bizarre situation" and criticised Sunderland City Council's planning department for not providing more time for the legal agreement to be completed.
However, developers said they were still committed to the student accommodation scheme at John Street and would be resubmitting plans, along with the required legal agreement, in "due course".
"Last week we found ourselves in a bizarre situation regarding the planning approval for 60 -66 John St development, which was reversed by the Planning Committee team due to the legal agreement not being fully completed, albeit our solicitor had written to the council’s solicitor to commence and progress the legal agreement," he said.
"However [...] the agreement needed to have been completed by September 4 which was not fully understood by us until too late.
"Ashbrookes have invested heavily in this development and have been very patient and collaborative with the planning function through the application process.
"We agreed extensions requested by Sunderland City Council due to the ongoing development and impacts of the Sunniside Conservation strategy and time taken for the various internal functions and consultations to review and reply to the scheme.
"We were not given any recourse or even a small time extension regarding the September 4 date and unfortunately [it was] a summer holiday period leading up to the September 4 deadline with staff and solicitors being away and it being the busiest time of the year for Ashbrookes, as we onboard and move in many hundreds of students.
"As a result we were unable to fully complete the legal agreement as required."
Mr Mushtaq questioned the procedure around the refusal and noted that planning officers "refused the previously agreed planning approval despite our efforts with both sets of solicitors to satisfy the legal agreement”.
He added: "Ashbrookes are committed to the development of the John Street site into purpose build student accommodation and so we will be resubmitting the planning application alongside the required legal agreement in due course once we have fully reviewed the response from Sunderland City Council and we have taken the opportunity to revisit any small improvements we may wish to request of Sunderland City Council's planning authority."
Council planning officers, speaking when the plans were last discussed at the Planning and Highways Committee in July, 2025, said an approach of issuing deadlines to progress delayed developments had previously been successful in “focusing minds”.
However, council planners stressed the process around completing such legal agreements were “bilateral between both parties”, namely the council and applicant.
In the case of the John Street development, it was noted that details around the storage of construction materials didn’t have to be resolved before the issuing of a planning decision, and could be a planning condition instead.
The applicant was previously listed as Ashbrookes Design and Build Ltd and developers said the firm has “experience of large schemes and considers that the group living concept […] promotes a sense of community, shared ownership and successful bonding between the students”.
The announcement in April, 2025, from ‘Ashbrookes Inspired’ said a contractor was “set to be appointed imminently” and that “pre-construction works inside the building have already begun”.
It was also noted that developers had “worked closely with the council to ensure the plans align with the Sunniside Masterplan, which focuses on the regeneration and conservation of the historic area.”
The John Street site once had signage advertising 'luxury student apartments' but at the time of writing, these signs were no longer in place.
For more information on the planning application and council decision, visit Sunderland City Council’s planning portal website and search reference: 23/02584/FUL