Sunderland's greatest Premier League XI - Echo launches new series with focus on centre-midfield

Which players make it into Sunderland’s all-time starting XI of the Premier League era?

Who are the greatest players in Sunderland’s Premier League history so far? It’s a big question, but one that we here at The Echo are keen to answer.

With Regis Le Bris’ men flying high in the top flight, now seems as good a time as any to get to the bottom of the debate, and so we’re turning to you, the fans, for your opinion. We’ll be running articles all week long on different positions, and asking you to vote in our polls every day on the Sunderland Echo’s X profile. We’re working our way up through the pitch, and with that in mind, we’ve picked out a few possible candidates for the title of Sunderland’s best-ever Premier League central midfielder.

Here are your four options for the centre-midfield spots in our best ever Sunderland Premier League XI

Granit Xhaka

Look, it’s very, very early days, but Xhaka’s impact has been so seismic, and his quality is so undeniable that it feels almost impossible not to include him on this list. An absolute midfield general who dictates matches with a measured ease which frequently borders on the world class, there are still times when you have to pinch yourself to double check that the veteran Swiss does, indeed, play for Sunderland. Captain, leader, warrior, maestro - Xhaka is already well on his way to becoming a modern Black Cats legend.

Yann M’Vila

We all know the cliche, ‘Never fall in love with a loan player’, but when said loanee is as brilliant as Yann M’Vila, that is much, much easier said than done. The commanding Frenchman injected a measure of combative class into the centre of the park during his brief stint on Wearside in 2015/16, and the clamour for him to return to the club - both at the time and more recently - is testament to just how well-regarded he was. In fact, the decision against signing him again the following summer, and instead drafting in Didier Ndong for a then-club record fee, still feels like one of the most baffling in Sunderland's recent past - and lord knows there have been plenty...

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

Lorik Cana

Before Granit Xhaka, there was Lorik Cana - the kind of signing that makes you go, 'How the hell have little old Sunderland pulled that off?'. Much like his Swiss successor, Cana arrived amid a groundswell of acclaim and was almost immediately made captain for the 2009/10 campaign. In a cruel twist, he would join Galatasaray on a permanent deal just one year later - only to make minimal difference to the Turkish giants before leaving them shortly after - but make no mistake, while he was at the Stadium of Light, he was a class act.

Stefan Schwarz

The club record signing with an infamous “space clause” in his contract, Schwarz signed for Sunderland from Valencia, and was soundly told that should he ever leave the Earth’s atmosphere, his contract would be deemed invalid. (Sounds utterly bizarre, until you realise that he’d already put a deposit down on the flights, just in case they ever became available...) Anyways, back on terra firma, the midfielder established himself as a massively popular figure at the Stadium of Light, registering 73 appearances, bossing the engine room, and earning a reputation as a genuinely lovely guy. He would eventually go on to retire at the end of his Wearside stint, in 2003.

Catch up on the previous positions in our best-ever Sunderland Premier League XI - goalkeeper, centre-back, and full-back - here.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice