Sunderland's greatest Premier League XI - Echo launches new series with focus on goalkeeping position

Which players make it into Sunderland’s all-time starting XI of the Premier League era?

Who are the greatest players in Sunderland’s Premier League history so far? It’s a big question, but one that we here at The Echo are keen to answer.

With Regis Le Bris’ men flying high in the top flight, now seems as good a time as any to get to the bottom of the debate, and so we’re turning to you, the fans, for your opinion. We’ll be running articles all week long on different positions, and asking you to vote in our polls every day on the Sunderland Echo’s X profile.

There’s no better place to start than between the sticks, and to that end, we’ve picked out a few possible candidates for the title of Sunderland’s best-ever Premier League goalkeeper. We’re giving readers the choice of four players for each position, so sadly it has come a little too soon for Robin Roefs, who has enjoyed a stunning start to life on Wearside. Is it a bit early to be mentioning the Dutchman in these kind of conversations? Perhaps, but on the early evidence of his Sunderland career, he has every chance of becoming a real cult hero on Wearside. Commanding and physically imposing, his shot-stopping has already earned Regis Le Bris’ men several points this season, and with every passing week, it looks more and more as if the Black Cats have unearthed a real gem. A player with a big, big future.

Here are your four options for the No1 spot in our best ever Sunderland Premier League XI

Thomas Sorensen

The popular Dane was parachuted in by Peter Reid in 1998, and would spend half a decade on Wearside before leaving to join Aston Villa. A relative unknown in England before completing his switch to Sunderland from his home country, Sorensen helped the Black Cats to promotion, and then established himself as a key figure at the Stadium of Light as Reid’s men finished seventh in each of their next two top flight campaigns. And, of course, there was the Wear-Tyne Derby penalty save against Alan Shearer back in November 2000 - a stop that preserved a 2-1 win at St. James’ Park...

Craig Gordon

In terms of pure shot-stopping ability, there are few goalkeepers across Sunderland’s history who can hold a candle to Gordon. The Scot signed for the Black Cats in 2007 for a then-record fee for a British goalkeeper, and made plenty of memorable saves during his time at the club. Injuries were incredibly cruel, and probably held Gordon back from realising his full potential at the Stadium of Light, but when he was good, he was borderline unplayable. Indeed, his stunning reflex save to deny Bolton Wanderers defender Zat Knight in 2010 was voted the greatest save in the 20-year history of the Premier League two years later.

Simon Mignolet

Mignolet spent three years with Sunderland before being sold for a tidy profit to Liverpool in 2013 - a sure sign that he had established himself as one of the finest and most reliable goalkeepers in the Premier League at that time. A string of stellar displays and remarkable saves earned him rave reviews, with Manchester City number one Joe Hart even labelling him the best goalkeeper in the top flight at one point.

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

Jordan Pickford

It is quite cruel that timing and circumstance prevented Jordan Pickford from playing for Sunderland for longer than he did. The academy graduate - still a favourite son on Wearside - only really had one full and proper season as the Black Cats’ preferred choice between the sticks, and even then, that was their ill-fated relegation campaign under David Moyes. Still, he was a standout performer that year - so much so that Everton made him the third-most expensive goalkeeper in history the following summer, and he earned himself a nomination for the PFA’s Young Player of the Season award. Since leaving the Stadium of Light, he has, of course, established himself as England’s de facto number one, and has often been the difference between the Toffees staying in the division or succumbing to the perilous pull of relegation.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice