Sunderland's greatest Premier League XI - Echo launches new series with focus on full-back positions

Which players make it into Sunderland’s all-time starting XI of the Premier League era?

Who are the greatest players in Sunderland’s Premier League history so far? It’s a big question, but one that we here at The Echo are keen to answer.

With Regis Le Bris’ men flying high in the top flight, now seems as good a time as any to get to the bottom of the debate, and so we’re turning to you, the fans, for your opinion. We’ll be running articles all week long on different positions, and asking you to vote in our polls every day on the Sunderland Echo’s X profile. We’re working our way up through the pitch, and with that in mind, we’ve picked out a few possible candidates for the title of Sunderland’s best-ever Premier League full-back.

Here are your four options for the full-back spots in our best ever Sunderland Premier League XI

Phil Bardsley

Hard-as-nails, no-nonsense, old school - Phil Bardsley was a great servant to Sunderland. The right-back spent six years on Wearside after signing from boyhood club Manchester United, and while he had some sticky moments - including a red card in a Wear-Tyne Derby - he more than made up for them with his general consistency and his refusal to shirk a full-blood challenge. And, of course, who could forget the goal he scored (with a little help from David de Gea) at Old Trafford to help the Black Cats on their way to Wembley in 2014?

Chris Makin

A real talent, and one who also turned to be an astute piece of business from Sunderland too. Makin was signed from French giants Marseille in 1997, helped the Black Cats to win promotion to the Premier League, and then continued to impress as they finished seventh in the top flight. A pacey player with plenty of grit to his game, he would eventually leave to sign for Ipswich Town after making 121 appearances in red and white, but not before the Black Cats tripled their money on him.

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

Micky Gray

A Sunderland lad who lived the dream, Gray played more than 350 times for his boyhood club, and even played his way into the England squad while the Black Cats were still in the Championship. When Peter Reid’s men did eventually make the step up to the Premier League, the left-back continued to shine, and was a stalwart of the side who secured successive seventh-placed finished in the top flight. Of course, relegation would follow, and he would eventually leave the Stadium of Light - first for Celtic on loan, and then for Blackburn Rovers - but for fans of a certain age, his name is still synonymous with one of the best periods in the club’s recent history.

Danny Rose

Maybe a little bit of a left-field shout (no pun intended) given the fact that he spent a relatively brief spell on Wearside, but for the duration of the 2012/13 campaign, he was brilliant. The left-back truly announced himself as a Premier League calibre player, winning the Black Cats’ Young Player of the Season accolade, and ultimately laying the groundwork for a career that would take him all the way to 29 England caps. By May 2013 he was back in North London with parent club Tottenham Hotspur, but not before making a considerable impact, to both his and Sunderland’s benefit.

Catch up on the previous positions in our best-ever Sunderland Premier League XI - goalkeeper and centre-back - here.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice