Sunderland's greatest Premier League XI - Echo launches new series with focus on centre-back position

Which players make it into Sunderland’s all-time starting XI of the Premier League era?

Who are the greatest players in Sunderland’s Premier League history so far? It’s a big question, but one that we here at The Echo are keen to answer.

With Regis Le Bris’ men flying high in the top flight, now seems as good a time as any to get to the bottom of the debate, and so we’re turning to you, the fans, for your opinion. We’ll be running articles all week long on different positions, and asking you to vote in our polls every day on the Sunderland Echo’s X profile. We’re working our way up through the pitch, and with that in mind, we’ve picked out a few possible candidates for the title of Sunderland’s best-ever Premier League centre-back.

Here are your four options for the centre-back spot in our best ever Sunderland Premier League XI

John O’Shea

A player who won it all with Manchester United during the first part of his career, but who still managed to have a really pleasing, if wholly different, Wearside swansong in his latter years. O’Shea signed for Sunderland in 2011, and would go on to make more than 250 appearances in red and white, playing his part in a series of improbable Premier League great escapes. A towering presence, he would even stay with the club after they dropped out of the top flight, before eventually leaving to wrap up his career with Reading.

John Mensah

Were it not for fitness setbacks, who knows how much Mensah could have gone on to achieve with Sunderland. The Ghanaian was an absolute rock during his two seasons on loan in the North East - or at least he was when he wasn't being plagued by various injuries. Signed from Lyon (twice), had it not been for his repeated stints on the treatment table, surely the Black Cats would have pulled the trigger on a permanent deal. Instead, they let him return to France in 2011, but make no mistake, when he did play, he was frequently a standout performer.

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

Younes Kaboul

Looking back on it now, Kaboul actually had a pretty rough start to life on Wearside after signing for Sunderland from Tottenham Hotspur in 2015. Struggling for form and fitness at various points, he was even labelled “the most ill-disciplined Premier League player ever” by one tabloid after a sending off against Bournemouth. Still, he turned it round - and in a big way. The Frenchman absolutely thrived under Sam Allardyce, and established himself as a key player before his time in the North East was cut short after he requested a move for personal reasons. If nothing else, though, we’ll always have that assist in the Wear-Tyne Derby...

Steve Bould

Another huge talent who ended up making limited appearances for Sunderland, Bould was nevertheless a massively impressive presence for Peter Reid’s side after they won promotion to the Premier League and subsequently went on to finish seventh. Of course, his best work came with Arsenal earlier in his career, and the Black Cats were very much treated to the tail-end of his majesty before arthritis contributed to a sudden retirement, but nevertheless, he deserves his recognition.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice