Habib Diarra and Luke O’Nien came under scrutiny after the Aston Villa defeat, but Sunderland’s collective performance tells a bigger story

There are defeats, and then there are defeats like this - the kind that linger long after the final whistle because they were within touching distance of something genuinely significant. Instead, Sunderland left Villa Park with nothing but the sense of what might have been.

With a little distance, though, the performance tells a more encouraging story. This was a display built on resilience and belief. From 3-1 down, away to a side chasing Champions League football, Sunderland refused to fold. They stayed in the game, found moments, and dragged themselves level at 3-3 deep into stoppage time. That does not happen by chance. It speaks to a group that is aligned and committed.

Habib Diarra’s late miss will inevitably dominate the narrative. The decision to chip Emiliano Martínez, rather than take a more assertive option, proved costly. Diarra will know himself that he should have done better. More established players have missed simpler chances in less pressurised moments. At 22, adapting to a new league and environment, he is still developing. Across the game, he contributed well and continues to trend in the right direction. If Sunderland supporters show the same patience they did with Enzo Le Fée earlier in the campaign, there is every reason to believe they will be rewarded.

Luke O’Nien, meanwhile, endured a difficult afternoon against Ollie Watkins, who remains one of the most complete forwards in the division when in form. There will be noise around that performance, as there always is with O’Nien. The truth, as ever, lies somewhere in between. He has shown flashes of competence in the Premier League, but there have also been several costly errors. He remains a valuable presence within the squad, but he is not without limitations, and at this level, those can be exposed.

Crucially, though, this was not about individuals. You cannot start both halves the way Sunderland did and expect to take something from a side of Aston Villa’s quality. Defensive issues were collective - lapses in concentration, a lack of pressure in wide areas, and moments where the structure broke down before the ball even reached the centre-backs. Those are the details that decide games at this level. And yet, despite all of that, Sunderland were still within seconds of winning it.

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

With five games remaining, they are still just two points off sixth place. Their rivals largely dropped points, and arguably their toughest fixture on paper is now out of the way. Frustration is natural, but it should not obscure the bigger picture. This is a newly promoted side going toe-to-toe with one of the strongest teams in the league and leaving disappointed not to have taken anything from their ground.

The run-in is unforgiving. Sunderland will have to earn a European qualification the hard way. But that is why the focus now has to be on the collective. Not on isolating individuals, not on overreaction. If it comes down to the final day, at home to Chelsea, with something tangible on the line, the Stadium of Light will be ready. That is the position this team has put itself in. That, in itself, says enough about the season they are having. That is what this team has given itself the chance to chase.

Your next Sunderland read: 'Too clever' – Roy Keane issues blunt verdict on Habib Diarra's Sunderland miss against Aston Villa