Exasperated Wearside couple ‘might as well have flown to Canaries’ after being hit with clean air zone fines
“We were just following our sat nav and when we got to the outskirts of Sheffield we didn’t see any signs about clean air zones”
An exasperated couple said they “might as well have flown to the Canary Islands” after being hit with hundreds of pounds of clean air zone fines.


Martin Sugden and his partner Nicky Gaillard travelled through Sheffield on their way to and from Castleton in the Peak District on March 31 and April 4. They also returned to the city in their 1997 Ford Transit campervan on April 1 to buy shopping.
Unbeknown to the Wearside couple, they’d passed through Sheffield’s clean air zone (CAZ), and seven months on are facing nearly £800 worth of fines and threats from bailiffs to clamp their beloved vehicle for falling foul of the city’s CAZ.
Employment coach Martin, 53, who lives in Easington, said: “We’ve already paid £270, and now face paying nearly £800 in total. We could have gone on holiday to the Canary Islands for the amount we’re expected to pay.
“When the first fine of £80 came through, we paid it, but we then a second fine arrived saying we now owed a further £190 for not paying the fine straight away, even though we had not received any notification.
“I was a bit miffed, but in the end I paid it.
“Months later, we then got a third fine notification from debt collectors Bristow & Sutor claiming we owed £527 for an unpaid CAZ fine, which I was told was due to not responding to several fine notifications from Sheffield City Council, even though we’d not received initial correspondence on this third fine.”


Martin is in the process of appealing this additional fine as he says his campervan should be exempt from CAZ fines.
After being contacted by the Echo, Sheffield City Council confirmed smaller campervans weighing less than 3.5 tonnes are exempt from fines, but they may ‘sometimes’ be classified as Light Goods Vehicles, which can be fined.
Sheffield City Council’s website states that motorists planning on travelling through the city need to apply in advance to qualify for exemption - something which Martin and Nicky admit they didn’t do.
Nicky, 51, a communications consultant from West Rainton, said: “We were just following our sat nav and when we got to the outskirts of Sheffield we didn’t see any signs about clean air zones. The first we knew was when we received the first fine.”


Martin added: “I’ve sent the council the vehicle plate confirming the maximum weight of the campervan is 3.3 tonnes and I’ve retrospectively applied for exemption.
“We go all over in our campervan, and how are we supposed to know we need to apply for exemption in advance of our journey? You would only know that if you have local knowledge.
“It’s very frustrating, and I can’t understand how the council think it’s justifiable, particularly the third fine of over £500, when we didn’t receive the initial notifications.”
Nicky added: “We’ve got no idea what to do next. The council told us to ring the bailiffs, who told us to ring the council. No one will look at our case and say, ‘that’s a campervan, that’s exempt’.”
After being contacted by the Echo, a spokesperson for Sheffield City Council said they can’t comment on individual cases and invited the couple to email the Parking Services Team directly.
They also confirmed the council is informed whether a vehicle is subject to a charge using information held by the Joint Air Quality Unit , which determines this based on the vehicle's classification and CO2 output.
We also contacted debt collectors Bristow & Sutor, but have not yet received any response.
Speaking at a recent Sunderland City Council meeting, council leader Chris Eynon confirmed there are no plans to introduce a clean air zone.
