Premier League’s Key Match Incident panel delivers verdict on four calls in Sunderland v Chelsea

Sunderland secured a crucial win before the international break against Chelsea at the Stadium of Light

The Premier League's Key Match Incident Panel has almost unanimously backed all of Jarred Gillett's big decisions in Sunderland's 1-0 win over Chelsea.

A crucial win for Sunderland swung on two big calls midway through the first half, with Gillett initially waving away claims for a foul on Cole Palmer when the forward went down inside the box. Minutes later, Gillett pointed to the spot when Brian Brobbey went down under a challenge from Levi Colwill.

The five-person independent panel is made up of three former players or coaches, one representative from ProRef and one from the Premier League. They meet each week to analyse significant decisions made in Premier League games and feed back to the game's refereeing body on how they feel top-tier games should be officiated.

Four of the panel ruled that while Luke O'Nien had fouled Palmer, the contact was outside the box. They also agreed that while Brobbey and Colwill had both been holding outside the box, the latter tripped the former as he progressed into the box.

"There was clear contact made by O'Nien on Palmer which the panel felt should have been penalised with a free kick on the basis that contact was made outside the area, 4:1," the notes from the panel read.

"One panellist felt that the foul contact occurred inside the area and a penalty should have been awarded."

On Sunderland's penalty, the notes read: "The referee's call of a penalty for a foul by Colwill on Brobbey was supported. There was upper body holding from both players as they progressed into the penalty area before a careless trip from the Chelsea defender." All five panellists supported that conclusion on Gillett's decision.

Join the Echo’s WhatsApp SAFC Channel for the latest news, team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join.

The panel also backed the decision not to take action against Morgan Rogers when he caught Trai Hume's head with his knee away from the ball in the second half.

They agreed that there was no conclusive evidence that proved it was deliberate: "The referee's call of no red card for violent conduct was supported with no clear evidence that this was a deliberate action by Rogers."

The panel also agreed with a decision not to award Sunderland a second penalty later in the game, arguing that Romeo Lavia had played the ball onto his arm and that no offence had therefore been committed.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice