The Sunderland AFC Q&A: Survival chances assessed, early January prediction, injury latest and Aston Villa test

Sunderland return to Premier League action when they face Aston Villa at Villa Park on Saturday afternoon

As Sunderland prepare for their return to action this weekend, Phil Smith gives his view on all the big talking points on Wearside in our Q&A...

What's the injury latest ahead of Saturday's game at Aston Villa?

As of yet, we are still awaiting official confirmation of Granit Xhaka and Brian Brobbey's issues which is likely to come when Régis Le Bris holds his pre-match press conference on Thursday afternoon. Both key players in Le Bris's side, they are major worries and it's thought that both are major doubts for the upcoming week of fixtures at the very least. Jules Ahoka's early return from international duty with DR Congo U23s is a reflection of the role he could have over the next few weeks, while Netherlands boss Xavi appeared to confirm a new injury issue for Brobbey last week.

Sunderland's last group of internationals are in action on Tuesday evening, and they will have everything crossed that Wilson Isidor in particular comes through unscathed.

Dan Ballard is making good progress in his recovery,but we're not expecting to see him, Habib Diarra or Romaine Mundle for a little while yet.

What changes is RLB likely to make for the Aston Villa game?

I strongly suspect any changes will be limited to those injury issues mentioned above. Ahoka for Xhaka, and Isidor for Brobbey if not fit. There's been too much disruption at the back this season and having kept a clean sheet against Chelsea, Le Bris will surely want to stick with that back four and particularly because they have all been on Wearside training and recovering for the past fortnight.

You could make a case for playing two wingers rather than Trai Hume in front of Meunier, but away from home against strong opposition is Le Bris likely to open his side up? It seems unlikely in the extreme and especially if Xhaka is absent. On the other flank, I think Chemsdine Talbi did enough to earn another start and a little run in the side.

How much did the win over Chelsea lift the pressure on Le Bris?

It was massive, but he knows very well that the journey is only just starting and he needs more results in this next block. What we can say for sure is that when you consider the other changes clubs have already made, Le Bris retains the support of the senior footballing leadership and ownership. They don't want to make a change, and on balance have rightly attributed this season's struggle so far to a lot of different factors. I think the intensity of the performance against Chelsea was big: it's clear everyone is behind him behind the scenes.

How are you feeling about Sunderland’s survival chances as things stand?

I have slightly mixed feelings, to be honest.

I do genuinely think by and large, Sunderland’s performances have been better than their results and that will even out a little bit over time. If you look at the Fulham, Leeds and Chelsea games, Sunderland have kept three clean sheets and been really competitive on occasions where Le Bris has been able to get something close to his best side and certainly his sturdiest defence out on the pitch.

Get Mukiele, Ballard, Meunier etc on the pitch at the same time and we’ll see those errors that have been so costly this season cutback and some good results follow. This has always been the million-dollar question though, hasn’t it: Can they avoid those big injuries with such a busy schedule both domestically and internationally? The potential injuries to Xhaka and Brobbey highlight how fragile things are for Sunderland given their squad at this stage isn’t as deep as teams around them who’ve been at this level far longer.

Join The Echo’s WhatsApp SAFC Channel for the latest news, team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join.

What do you make about the persistent rumours of a January move for Brian Brobbey?

We know that sales are going to part of the journey so Sunderland can reinvest under the SCR rules, but the reason they have been proactive with contract management is so they can do so on their terms. Brobbey's new deal means the club can resist offers in January, when he'd be almost impossible to replace. As with many players, next summer or the summer after that might be different but for now, I don't think there's cause for concern.

Sunderland’s summer spend was fairly modest by Premier League standards, and it means there’s no immediate pressure to sell to stay within the regulations. It would take an absolutely exorbitant bid to test Sunderland’s resolve and you have to strongly question whether that kind of market will be there in January. That Brobbey signed a new deal on Wearside is a reflection of his own happiness here and that he understands the environment he has isn’t to be taken for granted as he develops and looks to kick on to become that top, all-round centre forward.

For what it’s worth, I think the same applies to the likes of Robin Roefs and Noah Sadiki. These players won’t be here forever and particularly if Sunderland don’t get themselves out of trouble, sales are an absolutely inevitability. Like most January windows with Sunderland, though, I see this one being quite quiet.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice