The Sunderland AFC season so far player ratings with two 8/10s and clear room for improvement
Sunderland have had a difficult start to the campaign but enjoyed some big moments in the Premier League and cup competitions
Sunderland return to action at Villa Park this weekend hoping that their win over Chelsea can be a turning point after a difficult start to the Premier League campaign.
That the Black Cats still sit in the bottom three is a reminder of just how precarious their situation is, but they have cut the gap to the teams above them significantly and there is much football still to be played. Though they lost their last fixture against Dinamo Zagreb, Régis Le Bris’s side are also relatively well placed in the Europa League and are one win away from a Carabao Cup semi final.
So it has been a rollercoaster of a campaign so far, with contrast form and fortunes across the squad. Here, we take a closer look at how each member of Le Bris’s group have got on so far and what’s next…
GOALKEEPERS
Robin Roefs
There is no doubt that at this early stage, Roefs hasn’t been able to have quite the spectacular impact he had in the opening weeks and months of last season. Statistically his shotstopping numbers are down and Sunderland have conceded far more goals, and yet you’d also have to say that very few of those have been obvious errors from the Dutchman. In a lot of cases, he has been badly exposed by errors in front of him and had to pick the ball out of his net before getting into a game. Other areas of his game, such as dealing with set plays and his distribution, have largely remained solid.
There’s more to come from Roefs, but he also needs better protection as he had against Chelsea. 5.5/10
Melker Ellborg
It’s been a tough campaign so far for Ellborg, who might have hoped for opportunities in the Europa League only to be left out of the squad because of Sunderland’s struggles meeting UEFA’s tough registration rules. Has done well in his two Carabao Cup appearances, particularly against Brentford even though he made a late error. N/A
THE DEFENDERS
Thomas Meunier
When fit he has comfortably been one of Sunderland’s most consistent performers bringing experience and physicality. Never lets the side down and you’d think if he stays fit he is going to be a pillar of the side Le Bris looks to settle on to turn around the league form. 7/10
Trai Hume
Started the season in decent form but definitely suffered a dip after the last international break, in which he had played four times in 90 minutes for Northern Ireland. Dropped out of the XI at times which is very rare for him, but good against Chelsea to show what he can bring at his best. 6/10
Nordi Mukiele
No coincidence that he has started every game Sunderland have taken a positive result from, and at centre back in all of his side’s league clean sheets. You could make a strong case that he’s the most important player in the XI right now when the rest of the defence has struggled so much. Absolutely crucial to his team’s hopes of a strong campaign. 8/10
Omar Alderete
Looked to have turned a corner with solid displays against Leeds and Brentford before being shown a red card against Coventry City. No getting around it, it has been a very tough season so far for the defender who struggled for rhythm and looked short of his best form after some injury issues at the World Cup and through pre-season. 3.5/10
Dan Ballard
Was just finding his very best form when he suffered a hamstring injury on international duty. Has been a big miss and Sunderland need him back quickly. 6.5/10
Kevin Danso
Has struggled for form of late but easy to forget how well he played in the first part of the season after his arrival. Out of the XI in the league at the moment but will get opportunities in the cups. 4/10
Luke O’Nien
Had a tough afternoon on opening day at Ipswich Town, but responded to that setback well as he often does. Played his way back into contention in the cups and was an important part of the team’s more recent results. It has been up and down so far this season but put himself in a good position to kick on now. 6.5/10
Reinildo
While he maybe hasn’t quite hit last season’s levels in the main, he’s been one of the more dependable performers in a tough campaign so far for Sunderland. Superb against Chelsea, highlighting why Le Bris has stuck with him in the league. 7/10
Dayann Methalie
Has shown real promise and drive in some of his appearances but would have hoped to have made a bigger impact in the league. Time is on his side and there’ll be plenty of chances ahead. 5.5/10
THE MIDFIELDERS
Chris Rigg
Has picked up plenty of minutes across competitions but hasn’t quite been able to pin down a regular place and role in the side. That will be a source of frustration but he’s nevertheless picking up impressive exposure for such a young player. 6/10
Granit Xhaka
His form has been the subject of fierce debate and clearly he hasn’t been at the same level as last season, at times exposed on the break as Sunderland have struggled defensively. Even so, last season is a lofty level to judge against and he has remained his team’s best creative outlet by a distance. 6/10
Jules Ahoka
His season couldn’t have gone much better so far given how little experience in senior football he arrived with. While he has looked raw at times, he consistently made a positive impact in his cup appearances and his performance from the bench against Chelsea was absolutely superb. Looks a fantastic find and might be set for a big role in the weeks ahead given Xhaka’s injury. 8/10
Enzo Le Fee
Sunderland would be in a far worse predicament without his contributions and his by and large very good penalties. Even so, he’ll feel there is a little more to come in open play. To his credit, energy levels and work rate have never dipped despite the team’s form. 7.5/10
Habib Diarra
Couldn’t have made a better start with a huge impact from the bench in the win over Fulham but has suffered more injury frustration since then. Could be a massive play but needs a bit of luck. N/A
Noah Sadiki
An excellent performance against Chelsea was a big step in the right direction. One of many in the squad who before then had done OK without quite hitting last season’s levels. No doubt how much he can offer, though. 6/10
Alan Browne
Difficult for him not being in the Premier League picture or the Europa League squad, so credit to his professionalism that he has been ready to step in and contribute to two Carabao Cup victories. N/A
THE WINGERS
Chemsdine Talbi
A strange season so far. His momentum was badly disrupted by transfer speculation but he has gradually worked his way back into contention. Very good in the Carabao Cup and that led to his Premier League recall in recent weeks. Excellent against Chelsea and now surely set for a run in the XI. 6/10
Nilson Angulo
At times there has been real promise in his performances even if it is fair to say as of yet he hasn’t been able to find the consistency to make himself a must pick in the Premier League. Works tirelessly, to his credit, and that will earn opportunities. 6/10
Malick Fofana
Showed his ability and got his first goal for the club against Brentford in the Carabao Cup which was a welcome boost, but on the whole it hasn’t quite clicked for him yet. Works hard but seems to be a little short on rhythm and especially confidence on the ball. Sunderland will need him this season and he’ll surely improve over time, but it's hard to make a case for him to be in Le Bris’s strongest side at this stage. 5/10
Jocelin Ta Bi
One of a few who would have really benefited from Europa League exposure if not for Sunderland’s registration struggles. Made the most of his opportunities in the Carabao Cup where has been excellent, and will hope for some more Premier League minutes as a result. 6.5/10
Romaine Mundle
A good pre-season campaign earned a new contract before he suffered a significant knee injury. One a few players in the squad who desperately needs a bit of luck in the new year. N/A
Join the Echo’s WhatsApp SAFC Channel for the latest news, team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join.
THE STRIKERS
Brian Brobbey
When fit and at his best, he has been close to unplayable. If there was one criticism you could make, it’s that he hasn’t always been as clinical as Sunderland need him to be aside from that day at Man City. Still, having a huge impact and one of the first names on the teamsheet when available. Gives his side a chance in any game. 7.5/10
Wilson Isidor
Made good early contributions from the bench against Fulham and Brentford, but an injury slowed his momentum after the last international break. Could have a massive role to play in the weeks ahead if Brobbey is absent for any length of time, and will be eager to take the opportunity he has been waiting for if so. 5.5/10
Timur Tuteriov
Had a tough Premier League debut against Bournemouth but the circumstances of the game and the early red card gave him next to no chance. His hard work behind the scenes has paid off handsomely in the Europa League, where he has led the line at times and done so impressively well. Taken a huge step forward in his career. 7/10
Juan Riquelme Angulo
A bit of a surprise that Tutierov has moved ahead in the striker pecking order, but it’s very early days for the youngster who will need time to adapt to a new country and language. N/A
Your next Sunderland read: Timur Tutierov makes funny Brian Brobbey admission as Sunderland youngster reveals Wilson Isidor influence
