Made a brilliant stop from Guessand in the first half but will feel he should have saved Cash’s long-range strike. It did swerve late and significantly, but Roefs got his fists to the ball. First error of an otherwise excellent season. General work was good again. 5placeholder image
Made a brilliant stop from Guessand in the first half but will feel he should have saved Cash’s long-range strike. It did swerve late and significantly, but Roefs got his fists to the ball. First error of an otherwise excellent season. General work was good again. 5 | Getty Images

Phil Smith's Sunderland player ratings as stand-out 'titan' scores high vs Aston Villa

Sunderland produced a strong display to hold Aston Villa to a point with ten men

Sunderland battled back with ten men to secure a valuable point against Aston Villa at the Stadium of Light.

The hosts had been left with a mountain to climb after Reinildo saw red for a kick in the first half, and especially after Matty Cash’s long-range strike put the visitors ahead in the second. Sunderland played well, however, and got a deserved equaliser through Wilson Isidor.

Here’s how we rated all 16 Black Cats who took part in the game.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice