Phil Smith: My early predictions for Sunderland’s January window as key question emerges again

It is just six weeks until Sunderland and their rivals will have the chance to strengthen in the January transfer window

Sunderland's struggles in the early stages of the Premier League campaign offer up a fascinating early question: will it change their approach to the January transfer window?

The winter market is a notoriously difficult one in which to do good business, prices inflated and the genuine gamechangers very rarely available. It is not a window in which Sunderland have ever done major business under Kyril Louis-Dreyfus, and that is regardless of whether it has been Kristjaan Speakman or Florent Ghisolfi in charge of the footballing operation. Last January is a case in point: the first following Speakman's departure was officially confirmed. Sunderland did not depart from their usual strategy of keeping their powder dry for the summer but doubled down on it, their business following the usual pattern of investing in young players who would benefit from time in the building before they would be expected to take on a greater first-team role somewhere down the line.

Enzo Le Fée stands out as an obvious and high-profile exception to the rule, but even that initial loan deal was structured to significantly minimise the financial risk to Sunderland. The same applies to Jack Clarke and Patrick Roberts, ambitious signings in the context of the time but with a small initial outlay on the club's part.

Between now and the beginning of the window, much will change and that will undoubtedly guide how Sunderland approach it. Their currently perilous Premier League status may well have eased a little if they can build on that win against Chelsea, giving them greater breathing room to focus on the summer window as they usually prefer to do. With so many games still to be played between now and then, much will also rest on how the injury picture develops through the next section of this punishing schedule.

Should they still find themselves firmly in the thick of a relegation battle, then the reality of Premier League revenue means that there will almost have to be a shift in approach to try and strengthen the group to stave off the threat of the drop. The loan market is not one that Sunderland have used a great deal since winning promotion, but could emerge as a good compromise option.

Join the Echo’s WhatsApp SAFC Channel for the latest news, team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join.

Two obvious questions follow: How much resource will Sunderland have to invest and where might they look to strengthen?

Sunderland's net spend in the summer was one of the lowest in the Premier League, but that does not automatically mean that they are left with a significant war chest for January. Their spending following promotion is still relevant to this conversation because of the amortisation costs associated with it, while the Black Cats are also this season adjusting not just to the Premier League's SCR rules but UEFA's even stricter financial regulations. Their relatively modest spend last summer was specifically because they opted to keep together the team that had so thrived in the previous campaign, rather than freeing up funds for reinvestment within the regulations with one or two targeted sales. They will have scope to spend having been prudent in their approach over the last couple of windows, undoubtedly, but anyone expecting a sudden splurge may well have to be braced for disappointment.

As for the areas to strengthen, that is at once obvious and also tricky. Sunderland endured frustration in their efforts to strengthen at centre back and on the right wing in the summer, leading to a shift in approach as deadline-day approached. While initially the goal had been to sign a left-footed centre back, ideally a younger player with room to develop and comfortable in possession, the Black Cats brought in Kevin Danso as a ready-to-go Premier League centre back. And having suffered immense frustration in their bid to sign a natural right winger, Sunderland instead targeted Igor Paixão and then Malick Fofana reasoning that lifting the level of the team was a positive even if it left the squad a little unbalanced. As it stands, however, Danso and Fofana are not in Le Bris's strongest XI and there seems to be little immediate prospect of that changing. The investment in Fofana means that Sunderland simply have to give him time, while another huge investment in the centre of defence seems unlikely given that Danso will join for a significant fee if Sunderland beat the drop. They are nevertheless the two most obvious areas where Sunderland can improve their squad and help Le Bris, given the struggles he has faced finding consistency in both so far this season.

Poll a group of Sunderland fans as to their priority and another centre forward would probably come top of the list. Brian Brobbey has struggled with injury at times this season, and his presence is badly missed when not available. Interestingly, Le Bris was asked when Brobbey was last injured whether he expected the club to try and sign another 'number nine' in January and said that he did not. Sunderland's logic is that it is very difficult to recruit a centre forward when you only play with one and the hierarchy is already very clear. That thinking is unlikely to change in the near future, but might more injury issues or the pressure of the bottom three force a change when January does roll round? Unlikely, but not impossible by any means.

As for outgoings, it is certain to be a window in which the focus is on finding clubs for players in need of it. Though there might well be interest in key players including Brobbey, Sunderland are in a very strong position contractually which means they can block any significant exits at a time when replacements would be supremely difficult to find.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice