Three goals and key man's red card in wild Sunderland v Newcastle FM26 simulation

Football Manager 2026 predicts how Sunday's Wear-Tyne derby between Sunderland and Newcastle United will pan out.

The waiting is almost over as Sunderland prepare to host arch rivals Newcastle United in the Premier League for the first time in just over a decade.

Talk of the return of the Wear-Tyne derby started from the minute the Black Cats regained their Premier League status with a dramatic Championship play-off final win against Sheffield United in May - and it is Regis Le Bris’ men that will hold the upper hand ahead of Sunday’s clash.

As it stands, Sunderland are currently sitting one point ahead of their local rivals and could move back into the top five of the table if they can claim a fourth consecutive home league win against Newcastle and results elsewhere fall in their favour.

But how could Sunday’s game at the Stadium of Light pan out? What big calls do both managers have to make and what impact could they make on the game? We take to Football Manager 2026 to see how the world’s most popular managerial simulation believes both sides will fare as they eyes of the world fall upon the latest Wear-Tyne derby.

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates directly to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

An early lead for Sunderland as Le Bris call pays off

Screenshot from an FM26 simulation of Sunderland v Newcastle United (photo Sports Interactive)placeholder image
Screenshot from an FM26 simulation of Sunderland v Newcastle United (photo Sports Interactive) | Sports Interactive

One of the managers received an immediate reward for one of his major decisions ahead of the long-awaited derby as Regis Le Bris’ call to start Brian Brobbey in the lead role in attack paid off inside the opening five minutes. The former Ajax man broke in behind the Magpies defence after being played in on goal by Enzo Le Fee and kept his cool to slot the ball beyond the advancing Aaron Ramsdale to set off wild celebrations from the vast majority of those inside the Stadium of Light.

More justification for the Black Cats boss

Screenshot from an FM26 simulation of Sunderland v Newcastle United (photo Sports Interactive)placeholder image
Screenshot from an FM26 simulation of Sunderland v Newcastle United (photo Sports Interactive) | Sports Interactive

Those celebrations were kickstarted once again before the quarter-hour mark had even been reached and once again it was Brobbey that triggered them. Le Fee’s blistering start to his first ever Wear-Tyne derby continued as the French midfielder broke through two tackles before sending Brobbey into the left-hand side of the area and the striker wasted little time in firing beyond Ramsdale for a second time.

From bad to worse for the Magpies as key man sees red

Screenshot from an FM26 simulation of Sunderland v Newcastle United (photo Sports Interactive)placeholder image
Screenshot from an FM26 simulation of Sunderland v Newcastle United (photo Sports Interactive) | Sports Interactive

Things went from bad to worse for the Magpies as the half-hour mark was passed as they were reduced to ten men. A dangerous corner-kick routine broke down at the far post and that allowed Le Fee to carry the ball away from the Black Cats penalty area and over the halfway line. However, his run was cynically brought to an end by Magpies midfielder and captain Bruno Guimaraes, who was immediately shown a straight red card to leave his team right up against it.

Hope for the Magpies

Screenshot from a Football Manager 2026 simulation of Sunderland v Newcastle United (photo Sports Interactive)placeholder image
Screenshot from a Football Manager 2026 simulation of Sunderland v Newcastle United (photo Sports Interactive) | Sports Interactive

To their credit, Eddie Howe’s side kept battling away from they got some reward as they got back into the game on the midway point of the second half. Lewis Hall was the instigator of the move as the England full-back burst down the left-hand side and sent a pinpoint cross into the Black Cats area. That was met by Nick Woltemade and the Germany striker left Robin Roefs with no chance with a powerful header from close range - but would it be enough to kickstart a comeback from United?

Full-time

Screenshot from an FM26 simulation of Sunderland v Newcastle United (photo Sports Interactive)placeholder image
Screenshot from an FM26 simulation of Sunderland v Newcastle United (photo Sports Interactive) | Sports Interactive

The full-time whistle blows at the Stadium of Light and Sunderland have held on against a ten-men Newcastle side to claim a fourth consecutive home league win over the Magpies.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice