Régis Le Bris handed loud selection message as 2,219 Sunderland fans vote on Newcastle United call

A total of 2,219 supporters had their say on Sunderland’s striker choice for the derby, with a clear favourite emerging

Sunderland supporters have delivered a strong verdict to Règis Le Bris ahead of Sunday’s Wear-Tyne derby, with a fan poll showing a clear preference for Brian Brobbey to start up front against Newcastle United.

More than 2,200 fans voted in the survey, hosted on social media, and Brobbey finished well ahead of Wilson Isidor, collecting 70.6 per cent of the vote compared to Isidor’s 29.4 per cent. It is a decision Le Bris must weigh carefully, going into one of the biggest games of the season.

Isidor has started more often in recent weeks and continues to stretch defences with his pace in behind, but Brobbey has scored recent goals against Arsenal and Bournemouth and offers a more physical profile. In transition and in open space, Isidor has clear strengths, but Brobbey’s aggression, link play and ability to occupy centre-backs have resonated with supporters.

The replies to the poll reflected a strong belief that Brobbey’s physicality may be better suited to the occasion. Many fans referenced Newcastle’s size, the nature of the derby and the likelihood of a battle in both boxes. Paul Anderson wrote: "I’d go with Isidor, as he has the pace to terrify that lead-footed hoofer from Blyth…"

Tom Wilcock commented: "Better suited to the game. and like Isidor coming on fresh with home crowd," Oluwaseun Bamgboye said: "Brobbey because he can take on defenders and bully them." Nikki Jude suggested a split strategy: "Brobbey to beat up Burn for 70 mins then Wilson on to zip past him like Road Runner"

Joe Braun kept it simple: "Assuming it’s a physical game. I’d put Brobbey to start," Rachael Thexton added: "I’m becoming more frustrated watching Isidor. The last few games have been a hard watch. Too many opportunities to put it in the back of the net which he just can’t seem to capitalise on…"

Foz wrote: "Their defenders are quite physical, so I've said Brobbey to match that. Having said that, I think Wilson would be a good shout because he's more athletic than they are, although I think they'll match that by doubling up with their more athletic FBs. So Brobbey edges it." Mark agreed: "Got to be Brobbey. Strikers need to take their chances"

David McEwan shared a tactical concern: "Has to be Brobbey, as I have said on numerous occasions, Isidor is not a CF. Every time Roofes goes long through the middle, it comes straight back as Isidor never gets near the ball." Chris Major looked at the game state: "Isidor for pure pace! I do think the gap between the goalkeeper and centre halves changes for the opposition when he’s on the pitch. Would give Brobbey 30 depending on how it is going"

Aaron Charlton added another view: "Isidor seems to only score hard chances, big Brian has a better chance of netting the easier ones" Kevin Rain struck a different tone entirely, focusing on pride post-City: "Good team, but I couldn't be more prouder of this team." Lesley kept faith in big-game instincts: "Isidor, who always excels in big occasions!"

Malta Singh highlighted the Burn battle: "Brobbey has to start, his physicality and ability to hassle Dan Burn will be key." Chris said: "Brobbey is a bit more physically strong and hold up play is better than Isidor." Gaz Kay focused on execution: "I think Wilson presses and breaks better than Brobbey, but he needs to start and take his chances because strikers are judged on goals"

Craig Young argued for impact-sub use: "Isidor is a greater threat later in games when teams are tired or pushing to win." Jonathan echoed clinical concerns: "For me, Bobbey. I just think Isidor isn’t clinical enough in front of goal."

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates directly to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

Tony Schofield again referenced the Burn match-up: "Brobbey because he’s more direct and physical." Egon Ronnie highlighted the Enzo Le Fée partnership: "Wilson is more effective when Le Fée is on the ball." Con suggested timing matters: "Has to be Brobbey. He has the confidence, and the physicality to match Newcastle..."

The debate remains alive, and Le Bris’ selection will be scrutinised either way. Isidor bringing pace off the bench and Brobbey starting is a theme that runs strongly through supporter reasoning, but there are still vocal believers in Wilson leading the line from kick-off. What is clear from 2,219 votes is that the fanbase expects a physical derby and believes Brobbey is the man built for it.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice