Sunderland have been knocked out of the Carabao Cup after a second round defeat on penalties to Huddersfield Town.
Marc Guiu’s first Sunderland goal have levelled the game after Leo Castledine’s brilliant opener, but Milan Aleksic’s miss secured a 6-5 win on penalties for the League One visitors. Here’s how we rated all 14 of the Black Cats to feature in the contest..

9. RW - Patrick Roberts
Probably Sunderland’s liveliest player in the first half, albeit a little uncomfortable off the left. Some good runs in the second half without quite finding the killer ball he was looking for. 5 | Getty Images

10. ST - Marc Guiu
Struggled to get into the game through the first half but stuck at his task. Drew a good save from Nicholls early in the second half after a good touch to get away from his defender, and headed the equaliser into the far corner from Aleksic’s cross. 6 | Getty Images

11. ST - Wilson Isidor
Struggled to get into the contest in the first half but was Sunderland’s biggest threat after being moved onto the left in the second. Caused Huddersfield a lot of problems running in behind and driving infield. That might have caught Le Bris’s eye with Mundle out injured. 6 | Sunderland's Wilson Isidor. Photo by Chris Fryatt.

12. SUB: Jenson Jones
Steady senior debut for the young football, who was tidy defensively and got into advanced areas. 6 | Sunderland's Jenson Jones - Photo by Ben Cuthbertson Photo: Sunderland's Jenson Jones - Photo by Ben Cuthbertson


