James Copley: In defence of Wilson Isidor as Florent Ghisolfi’s transfer priority becomes clear amid Eliezer Mayenda debate

Wilson Isidor deserves some understanding, but Sunderland’s alarming attacking numbers raise questions for Florent Ghisolfi as the Eliezer Mayenda debate resurfaces

Any point away from home in the Premier League against a Champions League side is a good result. Sunderland’s performance at Aston Villa was hardly sparkling, but the goalless draw gave them something to build on after a worrying start to the campaign.

Four points from Chelsea at home and Villa away represents a return that most supporters would have gladly accepted before those fixtures. Consecutive clean sheets have restored some confidence, although Saturday also underlined problems Sunderland must address if this recovery is to last.

Going back to basics was necessary

Sunderland needed to get back to basics after damaging defeats against Bournemouth and Coventry. They were bottom after nine games, with individual errors becoming an alarming feature of their performances. Before asking how they might become more expansive, Le Bris had to stop his team making life so easy for opponents. The renewed defensive commitment against Chelsea and Villa has been encouraging.

Sunderland have now recorded four consecutive league games with less than one expected goal conceded. That is a good reaction to the Bournemouth and Coventry City debacles and suggests improvement beyond the clean sheets alone. There was a willingness to stay organised, compete and do the less glamorous work at Villa Park. Sunderland looked much closer to the side supporters expect in those respects.

Their 27 per cent possession also told its own story. Le Bris prioritised defensive security, accepted long periods without the ball and came away with a point. Given the circumstances, that was understandable. The next challenge is to retain those standards while giving opponents more to worry about.

Six games without an open-play goal

Sunderland’s first shot on target came from an Enzo Le Fée free-kick in the 72nd minute. That is a long time to wait, even against strong opposition away from home. More concerning is that only two of Sunderland’s opening 11 league matches have yielded a goal from open play. They have now gone six consecutive league games without one.

That is a worrying pattern, particularly when set alongside the wider attacking figures. Sunderland have scored just eight Premier League goals, ranking them last in the division. Their 129 shots placed them 16th, while 37 efforts on target ranked 18th. Expected goals stood at 12.7, also 16th, and their shot conversion rate of 6.2 per cent was the league’s second lowest.

Those numbers suggest problems with both creating opportunities and taking them. Sunderland are underperforming their expected goals total, but the volume and quality of chances also need to improve. Supporters can appreciate the effort, organisation and improved resilience while wanting more ambition with the ball. Four points from two difficult fixtures should be welcomed, but Sunderland badly need a greater attacking threat.

Isidor needs service that suits him

Wilson Isidor has taken some criticism for his display against Villa, and there were frustrating moments. Too often, his runs ended with an offside flag or without a teammate finding him. There is context, though. He had played 88 minutes and then another full match for Haiti during the international break, before making the long journey back.

To my eye, that workload appeared to affect his performance. He looked tired, and I think he needs a run of Sunderland games to build rhythm. There is also a serious discussion to be had about whether the current attacking patterns help him. Isidor’s strengths are his movement, pace and ability to attack space on the break. Holding the ball up with his back to goal is less suited to him.

Sunderland’s patient build-up did little to bring those qualities into play. Too often, the opportunity to release him had disappeared before the pass arrived. He must time his runs better, but the players supplying him also have to recognise them earlier. That understanding needs to improve if Isidor is to contribute more, though there is little doubt that, as an individual, he must also perform better.

January must bring another option

Brian Brobbey’s injury is unfortunate, but it has exposed how limited Sunderland’s alternatives are. With him unavailable, Isidor is the only established senior centre-forward Le Bris currently appears willing to trust in the Premier League.

Black Friday deal: get a whole year of the Sunderland Echo for just £12. That's £1 a month, saving over 75% on the usual £49.99 a year. New subscribers only. Offer ends Thursday 3 December.

Timur Tutierov works hard and has done well in the cups, but I do not think he is ready to carry that responsibility in the league. Summer signing Juan Riquelme Angulo is also yet to convince Le Bris that he is ready. When an exhausted Isidor went off against Villa, Nilson Angulo went through the middle. That decision illustrated the shortage of options.

Florent Ghisolfi must surely recognise the need for another striker in January. It is a difficult window in which to find value, but a loan could offer a solution. Sunderland need someone capable of contributing immediately and giving Le Bris another way to change a game.

Mayenda’s sale still made sense

Eliezer Mayenda’s departure has inevitably returned to the conversation. I loved watching him at Sunderland and understood why supporters were disappointed to lose him. However, he wanted to leave and play regularly. The package offered by Rennes represented excellent money, particularly in terms of Sunderland’s squad cost ratio position, and I still think accepting it was the right decision.

Mayenda also went into this weekend still awaiting his first competitive goal for Rennes. His potential remains considerable, but assuming he would have solved Sunderland’s current problems overlooks the uncertainty that comes with a developing striker. His departure has nevertheless left Sunderland short when Juan Riquelme Angulo is not yet a viable alternative. That gap needs addressing. Better defending has provided a platform. Scoring enough goals will be essential to survival.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice