College's expansion plan dealt blow despite finding ideal location with several empty buildings
A college provider’s bid to open a new campus on Wearside has been blocked, following council concerns it would "unacceptably dilute" the role of a business park safeguarded for "primary employment" uses.
Sunderland City Council’s Planning and Highways Committee, at a meeting this week, refused a planning application for 1 Grayling Court in the Doxford International Business Park.


According to a planning statement submitted to the council, UKMC offers BA (Hons) courses in business management, digital marketing management and health and social care, as well as BA (Hons) fashion design, event management, hospitality and tourism and more.
A previous supporting statement from the applicant noted “employability skills will be embedded in the curriculum” and that “companies aligning with the curriculum [would be] invited for guest lectures, potentially taking our students for placements or summer internships and to work together on research projects with our students and staff."
Sunderland City Council said the site was in a Primary Employment Area, a status which “safeguards” the area for certain business uses such as offices, general industrial and storage and distribution, “which are considered essential to the long-term success of Sunderland”.
Council officers asked the applicant to provide a justification for an exception, with college provider UKMC stating its plan would deliver “long-term use stability”, while providing “immediate educational provision for over 1,500 students and 40-60 staff”.
The applicant added the plans “satisfied and exceeded” the test due to the earmarked building’s “persistent vacancy despite sustained marketing”, viability issues with traditional office uses at the business park, the proposed college plan’s “direct alignment with city-wide educational and economic priorities” and more.
The council planning policy team’s response, posted on the local authority’s planning portal website, said the college proposals were not of “sufficient scale or merit to meet the exceptional thresholds” and that the “supporting statement does not indicate the uniqueness of the proposed development or how it differentiates in any substantive way to any other college activity.”
A planning statement submitted with the new application noted that “given the high vacancy levels at Doxford International Business Park, there is considered to be sufficient flexibility within the city’s overall employment land supply to justify the proposed change of use”.
Those behind the resubmitted college campus plan said “future employment needs are being actively met within central Sunderland through a pipeline of new development, reducing the strategic reliance on out-of-centre sites like Doxford International Business Park”.
It was argued that the "introduction of an educational facility in this location would not undermine employment land objectives but would instead deliver significant economic and social benefits, including skills development, job creation and sustainable reuse of vacant built stock.”
Councillor Heather Fagan, a representative for the city’s Doxford ward, also called the application into Sunderland City Council’s Planning and Highways Committee for consideration.
Cllr Fagan referenced "numerous empty buildings" at Doxford International Business Park and asked decision-makers to give "fair consideration to alternative uses", as well as describing the proposed college plan as a "suitable use.”
Council planners stressed the college bid was “unacceptable in principle” because the development “involves the introduction of a non-employment use to a Primary Employment Area” and noted the development had “not demonstrated compelling exceptional circumstances" to allow the proposal.
It was noted that the development, if approved, would “result in the loss of prime employment land in the city” in conflict with planning policy and that while evidence had been provided by the applicant, council planners said it "does not indicate the uniqueness of the proposed development or how it differentiates in any substantive way to any other college activity".
The council committee report added that the proposal would “result in the unacceptable dilution of Doxford International’s role as a Primary Employment Area by eroding the space available for appropriate uses.”
Arguments for and against the college plans were presented to councillors on the Planning and Highways Committee at a meeting on February 2, 2026, at City Hall.
Council planners, in a presentation to councillors, said the maximum number of people proposed on site under the college plans would be 175, with 25 staff and 150 students.
They also confirmed the application was being treated as retrospective as the applicant confirmed in mid-January, 2026, that the site was "operational", although an agent for the applicant later clarified this was a "light use of the building" and that the site was "not fully operational yet."
Supporting planning documents from the applicant previously described UKMC as “a franchise private educational institution” and noted the applicant was “hoping to work with University of Sunderland.”
However, councillors at Monday's planning hearing were told that the University of Sunderland had confirmed it would not be entering into any collaborative partnership or arrangement with UK Management College.
During discussion of the planning application at City Hall, a representative for the applicant urged councillors to make a "sensible and pragmatic planning decision" on the proposed college .
The applicant's representative noted that the college plans were initially withdrawn and then resubmitted to allow for a call-in request from Doxford councillor Heather Fagan, so that a decision on the college could be made by councillors on the Planning and Highways Committee.
It was also noted that working patterns had changed following the Covid-19 pandemic with home working and hybrid working and that, combined with new office developments in Sunderland city centre, there was less demand for office space at Doxford International Business Park.
The applicant's representative maintained the college development would have several benefits, including the reuse of a long-term vacant building for a use that will increase local skills and create jobs, and said the Sunderland site was chosen due to public transport links, the nature of courses offered and the opportunity for close relationships with existing businesses at the business park.
During debate on the plans, a number of councillors raised concerns about the recommendation from council planners to refuse the college provider's proposed development.
Councillor Martyn Herron asked why it was "preferable for [the building] to be empty than to be used" and said the policy reason behind council planners' recommendation for refusal appeared to be "almost red tape for the sake of it".
"I understand that we have our plans and strategies but I don't think we want to be seen as a city that doesn't encourage education and doesn't encourage educational facilities, particularly specialised ones like these," Cllr Herron added.
"This would bring people into Sunderland from across the region, I'm sure there's no coincidence that it's next to the A19 roundabout, there will be people coming from the south, the north, from County Durham and plan or not, I don't think that I want to refuse this."
Councillor Andrew Wood also questioned the "exceptional circumstances" point raised by council planning officers, noted the business park's transport links and college development's benefits around future employment and added the council's plans should be "more flexible".
"We need to be encouraging this and yet the statement appears to be anywhere but here but I'm not sure where else in the city that would be," Cllr Wood said.
"Here's an active use of a building that was and continues to be empty, which is the difficulty that Doxford International currently has, ideally the people who are being educated there see the potential of Doxford International and the empty buildings therein and make use of them.
"It could engender further use of that area that is already blighted by the fact that there's a large amount of working from home."
Council planners defended their recommendation to refuse the college, noting that changes to key employment areas needed to be strategic, comprehensive and evidence-based as part of a city-wide employment land review, rather than "allowing piecemeal loss" of a Primary Employment Site(s).
The council's planning department noted that planning applications which are not in accordance with the council's plan "put the rest of Doxford [Business] Park at risk as well."
Councillor Dianne Snowdon noted an educational use on employment land had previously been allowed at the International Advanced Manufacturing Park in the form of training facilities near Nissan, and asked whether the college in the Doxford area was a similar facility.
Council planners, responding, said the example cited represented "exceptional circumstances" as the educational use needed to be close to Nissan.
In the case of the UKMC development, council planners said it had not been demonstrated why the campus needed to be based at Doxford International Business Park, and that there were other locations in the city where it could be placed.
Cllr Snowdon, who later voted for refusal in line with the recommendation from council planners, said she "didn't feel she could ignore the local plan in this case without it being fully reviewed, which is something I don't want to do at the moment."
Councillor Lynne Dagg, who also supported the council planners' recommendation for refusal, said policy requirements asked of UKMC would be a "standard" that would also be asked of other educational establishments seeking a similar use at Doxford International Business Park.
Cllr Dagg added that the applicant had "crossed the threshold" to have a presence at the business park and while not being opposed to other sites, "didn't see that this site at this time is necessarily the best solution."
A proposal from Cllr Wood and Cllr Herron to approve the plans, against the advice of council planning officers, was initially put to the vote but failed to win majority support.
After being put to a final vote, the college plans at Doxford International Business Park were refused by a slim majority of three votes in favour of refusal and two votes against refusal.
Those behind the proposed college campus scheme said it would “deliver significant economic and social benefits, including skills development, job creation, and sustainable reuse of vacant built stock”, as well as “upskilling local students who may go on to work locally, including at Doxford International Business Park itself.”
The applicant has the right to contest the council refusal decision by lodging an appeal with the Secretary of State.
For more information on the planning application, or to track its progress, visit Sunderland City Council’s planning portal website and search reference: 25/02722/FUL