The Black Cats beat Sheffield Wednesday 2-1 on aggregate to reach the final, while Wycombe battled past MK Dons by the same scoreline over two legs.
Both sides set up with a 4-2-3-1 formation in the semi-finals but have also played with a back three this campaign.
For a bit of fun we’ve made a combined starting XI with players from both clubs.
Here’s who made the cut:
9. CAM: Alex Pritchard (Sunderland)
It's been a joy to watch the playmaker at times this season and it's just a shame he has missed parts of the season due to injury setbacks. The 28-year-old returned to the starting XI at Morecambe on the final day of the regular League One season and started both matches against Sheffield Wednesday in the play-offs. Photo: JPI Media
10. ST: Nathan Broadhead (Sunderland)
The Everton loanee, 24, came off the bench in the second leg against Wednesday following another injury setback. When he has played this season, the forward has been prolific in front of goal, scoring 10 times in just 21 League One appearances. Photo: JPI Media
11. ST: Ross Stewart (Sunderland)
What a season it's been for the Scottish frontman, who has scored 25 goals for the Black Cats. That includes a crucial goal at the Stadium of Light in the play-off semi-final against Wednesday. Photo: FRANK REID 2022