Is 'second season syndrome' a myth as Sunderland look to a bright Premier League future
Sunderland have enjoyed a positive first season back in the Premier League - but what could lie ahead?
Regis Le Bris has already made his feelings known over whether he and his Sunderland players fear the ‘second season syndrome’ in the Premier League.
The Black Cats have enjoyed an overwhelmingly positive first season back in the top flight of English football and remain in the race for a European place as the campaign enters its final month. But what about could lie ahead of Le Bris and his squad as they look to establish themselves as mainstays in the Premier League next season?
When asked about the famed ‘second season syndrome’ recently, the Black Cats boss said: "We'll see, it shows once again that you have to grow and move forward. Otherwise, if you stay at the same level, you get finished really quickly. It's clear in our mind that we have to improve our team. We have to improve our club, we have to improve our coaching staff. I have to improve my game model and the way I manage the team. It's the mindset of the club. After that, you never know the [level of] the competition and the opponent."
The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.
But what do the statistics tell us about second season syndrome and is it a genuine fear for clubs? The Echo has assessed the previous six Premier League seasons and analysed how every newly promoted club has fared throughout that time. Firstly, there is a clear sign showing just how difficult it is to avoid relegation back into the Championship with just seven of the 18 clubs promoted preserving their top flight status and securing a second year in the Premier League.
However, the picture is more encouraging for those clubs as only one of the seven has suffered relegation in their second season. There have been some success stories and many of those clubs have struggled during their second season - but they have fought successful battles against the drop and some of them have actually thrived.
2024/25 Leicester City, Ipswich Town, Southampton
Leicester City first season - 18th (relegated) Ipswich Town first season - 19th (relegated) Southampton first season - 20th (relegated)
Not a vintage season for newly promoted clubs as Leicester, Ipswich and Southampton all made immediate returns to the Championship just 12 months after securing their place in the Premier League. This continued a pattern that had been set during the previous season.
2023/24 Burnley, Sheffield United, Luton Town
Burnley first season - 19th (relegated) Sheffield United first season - 20th (relegated) Luton Town first season - 18th (relegated)
Burnley have become the ultimate yo-yo club in recent seasons and much like the current campaign, they found themselves making a quick return to the second tier after finishing in the bottom three just 12 months after securing promotion. They were joined in the second tier by two familiar opponents as Sheffield United and Luton Town were also relegated after a one-season stay in the top flight.
2022/23 Fulham, Bournemouth, Nottingham Forest
Fulham first season - 10th Fulham second season - 13th Bournemouth first season - 15th Bournemouth second season - 12th Nottingham Forest first season -16th Nottingham Forest second season - 17th
Now this is more promising! Fulham, Bournemouth and Nottingham Forest all survived their first season back in the Premier League after securing promotion - and even more encouragingly, all three remain in the top flight to this day. Their second seasons ended with bottom half finishes but they did survive and are still in the Premier League now - although Forest remain in the battle to avoid relegation.
2021/22 Norwich City, Watford, Brentford
Norwich City first season - 20th (relegated) Watford first season - 19th (relegated) Brentford first season - 13th Brentford second season - 9th
Norwich City and Watford were immediately relegated back to the Championship after a one-year stay in the Premier League - but Brentford bucked the trend for this particular season by ending their first year into the top flight just below mid-table before building on solid foundations to secure a top ten finish during their second season in the Premier League.
2020/21 Leeds United, West Bromwich Albion, Fulham
Leeds United first season - 9th. Leeds United second season - 17th. West Bromwich Albion first season - 19th. (Relegated) Fulham first season - 18th (relegated).
Much like the previous season, two newly-promoted sides were sent back to the Championship after just a solitary season in the Premier League as West Bromwich Albion and Fulham finished in the bottom three in a season impacted by the Covid-19 pandemic. However, Leeds United, then managed by Marcelo Bielsa, remained in the top tier by securing an impressive top ten finish before narrowly avoiding relegation on the final day of their second season with a dramatic win at Brentford.
2019/20 Norwich City, Sheffield United, Aston Villa
Norwich City first season - 20th (Relegated). Sheffield United first season - 9th. Sheffield United second season - 20th (relegated) Aston Villa first season - 17th. Aston Villa second season - 11th.
Of the newly promoted sides, only Norwich City were relegated back into the Championship after a single season in the top flight. Aston Villa survived in a tense relegation battle before achieving a mid-table finish in the second season back in the Premier League - but Sheffield United were relegated as the division’s basement club in their second season after securing a stunning ninth place finish in the aftermath of their promotion into the top flight.
