Phil Smith: Making sense of Sunderland's Premier League reality check - and what needs to happen next

Sunderland have suffered back-to-back league defeats for only the second time this season

It has been a bruising week for Sunderland, and one that perhaps has served as a bit of a reality check about where they stand within the Premier League pyramid.

Which is not to overreact, nor to diminish what has been achieved this season. The fact is that off the back of the win over Newcastle United at St James' Park last month, one that all but secured safety, Sunderland could have been beaten in every fixture that remained and the campaign would still on balance have been a success.

A win over Spurs rightly raised talk of Europe, Sunderland within striking distance of the top eight (remarkably, they still are despite their last two results). After the 5-0 defeat to Nottingham Forest, that excitement feels a little giddy. Régis Le Bris, perhaps the Premier League head coach least prone to hyperbole, said the first half in which his side shipped four goals felt like a punch in the face. Sunderland have particularly in defensive areas dropped off the pace and Premier League gravity has dragged them back towards the lower end of midtable.

It's a moment for reflection, but not for panic. When you look at the depth of their squads, how much they have cost to assemble and the length of time at which the clubs have now been established at this level it is perhaps no surprise that Brighton and Bournemouth are beginning to go through the gears as Sunderland hit a bump in their road. It is also not overly surprising that having taken four points off Aston Villa and Nottingham Forest earlier in the season, Sunderland found themselves on both occasions facing a different beast second time around. It seems incredible now to recall that Unai Emery's side played for over an hour with an extra man at the Stadium of Light, getting a point only because Robin Roefs made a very rare error in finding himself unable to keep out Matty Cash's long-range effort. Nottingham Forest were when Sunderland travelled to the City Ground an absolute mess, but still dominated that game. The Black Cats took three points thanks to a set piece goal, some stout defending and a fair amount of luck. Sunderland are a better, more rounded team then - highlighted by the levels of performance they have been able to reach away at Bournemouth, Newcastle and at home to an admittedly ailing Spurs side.

They are heading broadly in the right direction, but the fact remains that the gap to sides like Villa and Forest at their very best remains a significant one. Just look at the starting XI Vitor Pereira was able to field on Friday night: Could anyone argue this was a collection of players who should be scrapping at the bottom of the league? On squad depth, squad cost and squad experience at this level in particular, they should have finished ahead of Sunderland this season 99 times out of 100 even accounting for the Black Cats' ambitious summer window.

Having for much of the campaign over-performed against their performance data, Sunderland have also perhaps inevitably suffered something of a reversion. Almost every mistake they have made across the two games has resulted in the ball flying into the back of their net, nine goals conceded from an XG of under four.

It is perhaps more of a surprise that Sunderland have not felt the sharp edge of this level of clinical finishing from top forward players more often, and it is testament to their general consistency across the campaign that this only the second time across the whole campaign that we have had to stew over back-to-back defeats. Is it a concern that those runs have come in relatively close proximity and that the general trend of results is downward since the turn of the year? Undoubtedly. Is it also understandable and in fact probably inevitable as a small squad edges towards the end of a long campaign? Also yes.

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

What has to happen next at Sunderland

Sunderland were defined in the first half of their campaign by a remarkable intensity, where even if the football was 'not brilliant' as Le Bris would say with classic understatement, they could compete more often than not. Criticism of their indifferent XG numbers was fair but always a little bit reductive, too often failing to grasp the fact that Sunderland had not just accepted their status as underdogs this season but embraced it. This was a squad built to defend their box bravely and to pounce on the break. It should not be a major surprise that with the main goal of the campaign achieved and with fatigue both physical and mental taking hold, Sunderland have not quite been able to sustain it - especially against teams fighting for something as crucial as Champions League football or survival.

The challenge for Sunderland now is to find the right balance between honest reflection and staying calm. Over the course of the campaign they have developed well as a team, able to control the ball better for longer periods and to trouble the opposition with their high press. It is been a slow and steady process rather than a rapid one, but they have more strings to their bow now than they did when they made that fast start. This is crucial: they will not enjoy the surprise factor next season and it's vital that this summer transfer window sees them add more depth and more quality to their squad. The last two weeks, however, have also underlined that they cannot afford to move too quickly. First and foremost, they have to rediscover and protect the foundation of their success. They have been too easy to play against, having for so much of the season given their opposition an almighty headache. As Le Bris and Florent Ghisolfi would say, they have to Be Sunderland.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice