So close to Garner’s penalty having guessed the right way, but just beaten. Didn’t have too much to do throughout the rest of the contest and then shone in the shootout, saving all three. Held his nerve sensationally well. 9 placeholder image
So close to Garner’s penalty having guessed the right way, but just beaten. Didn’t have too much to do throughout the rest of the contest and then shone in the shootout, saving all three. Held his nerve sensationally well. 9 | AFP via Getty Images

Phil Smith's Sunderland player ratings v Everton as duo impress and penalty star lands 9

Phil Smith
By Phil Smith

Sunderland AFC Writer

Published 10th Jan 2026, 15:11 GMT

Sunderland won 3-0 on penalties to book their place in the fourth round of the FA Cup

Sunderland were back in action on Saturday as they faced Everton in the third round of the FA Cup.

After a 1-1 draw across 120 minutes, Sunderland won 3-0 on penalties.

Here’s how we rated all the Black Cats involved on the day...

Really struggled to get into the game and was replaced midway through extra time. Hopefully not an injury concern. 5

13. Sub - Brian Brobbey

Really struggled to get into the game and was replaced midway through extra time. Hopefully not an injury concern. 5 | Chris Fryatt

Photo Sales
Brought some extra energy in the latter stages but little sight of goal. N/A

14. Sub - Wilson Isidor

Brought some extra energy in the latter stages but little sight of goal. N/A | Getty Images

Photo Sales
Previous
4 / 4
Next Page
Related topics:SunderlandEvertonPhil SmithPlayer ratings
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice