What I noticed and who impressed as Sunderland U21s took on Sheffield Wednesday this week

Sunderland U21s were beaten 2-0 by Sheffield Wednesday in midweek but there were positives for the Black Cats

If you wanted a quick reminder of how far Sunderland have travelled and how quickly, watching their U21s take on Sheffield Wednesday at Hillsborough in the same competition their seniors won just six years ago certainly does the trick.

Just as it was when Sunderland competed at this level, the now Jersey Mike's Trophy remains a largely unloved competition and it's impossible to disagree with the general assessment that the introduction of Premier League academy sides has detracted from the tournament that gave lower-league clubs and their fans their best shot at a memorable Wembley outing.

Equally, it's clear why the competition works for Premier League clubs like Sunderland. Sheffield Wednesday rotated heavily as you would expect, and yet retained a core of senior players in both halves. Barry Bannan played 45 minutes, while Mason Burstow and Jamal Lowe shared the striking duties over the course of the game. As such, it was as close to a proper competitive game as the club's youngsters and senior players in need of some match fitness could get.

Henrik Pedersen's side ultimately ran out 2-0 winners and on balance of play it was a deserved win, the hosts the better team as you would expect given their additional experience and seniority. Sunderland were nevertheless competitive, having a goal ruled out and creating some golden chances. A number of their young players will feel they pressed their case not just to their club, but to any EFL side who might have been watching with an eye on a January loan move.

Luke O'Nien got 90 minutes under his belt ahead of a busy month for Sunderland, while Alan Browne also topped up his match fitness in a competitive environment. Though O'Nien erred in the build-up to the opening goal as his misplaced pass under pressure near the corner flag was pounced, it's also worth noting that his willingness to keep taking the ball and stepping into an aggressive press was a key reason the Black Cats were able to get a foothold in the game at times. Similarly, Browne's most high-profile moment in the game came when he missed a huge opportunity to level the scores just before the break, but he had a solid game on the whole and kept the side ticking in midfield. Both looked understandably rusty at times, but will be better for the outing if and when they are needed in the weeks ahead.

Join the Echo’s WhatsApp SAFC Channel for the latest news, team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join.

The big positives for Sunderland from an U21 perspective came from a number of very accomplished displays. New Zealand youth international Alex Lienard had an excellent game at right back, comfortable in possession and getting through a lot of defensive work. Still just 17, he looked impressive and composed despite the step up in level. Charlie Dinsdale, 19, made good progress in pre-season and again offered an outlet out wide while Tom Proctor continues to go from strength to strength. His progress in a matter of months has been remarkable, and on display once again was his willingness to play forward but also an unselfish streak in the final third. The 17-year-old of course still has much to improve, but is emerging as a real prospect for the club alongside 18-year-old goalkeeper Joe Cowan who made some smart stops here.

Having lost on penalties to Accrington Stanley in their opening group game, Sunderland now need to beat Salford City next month and hope that Sheffield Wednesday do them a favour when they face Accrington. If they can replicate this performance, they will have a genuine chance.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice