‘Not up for it’ – Sunderland criticised by national journalist after shock FA Cup defeat to Port Vale

Sunderland suffered a shock FA Cup defeat to Port Vale, with criticism aimed at their performance

Telegraph journalist Luke Edwards believes Sunderland were “not up for it” during their shock FA Cup exit to League One strugglers Port Vale on Sunday.

Régis Le Bris’ side travelled to Vale Park as overwhelming favourites but were beaten by a determined Vale team who currently sit bottom of League One and 11 points adrift of safety. Despite that difficult domestic campaign, the hosts produced a committed display to secure a famous result and reach the FA Cup quarter-finals for the first time since 1954.

Sunderland entered the tie ranked 57 places above their opponents in the English football pyramid, but struggled to match Port Vale’s intensity throughout the contest. Speaking on BBC Radio 5 Live’s Football Daily podcast, Edwards said the Black Cats’ energy levels were noticeably below the standards they have typically shown this season.

“I do think Sunderland turned up and weren't as focused as they should have been,” Edwards said. “I've watched them play a lot of times this season, and the energy levels and intensity were not the same. When they are at it, they are physical, intense, relentless, and they were not that. They tried to play a slow game. I'm sure they didn't turn up there expecting to win, but I don't think they were as laser-focused and up for it as they should have been.”

Edwards added that Sunderland’s lack of sharpness helped create the conditions for one of the competition’s biggest shocks of the round. “That's why FA Cup shocks happen. It was Port Vale's cup final, and Sunderland were not up for it,” he said.

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

The performance was particularly striking given the contrast in league positions and recent form between the two sides. “Port Vale have had a difficult season, but none of what had gone before mattered,” Edwards continued. “They should have been tired and exhausted after that brilliant win over Bristol City a few days earlier, but they had more energy than Sunderland.”

The result ensured Vale’s memorable cup run continued while Sunderland were left to reflect on a significant missed opportunity, with the Black Cats having been just one win away from reaching the quarter-finals and two wins away from another Wembley game.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice