Sunderland and Newcastle United fan groups unite in plea to Labour mayor over derby travel restrictions
Supporters on both sides of the Tyne-Wear divide have joined forces as concerns grow over derby arrangements
Sunderland and Newcastle United supporters’ trusts have jointly called on North East mayor Kim McGuinness to help secure answers over controversial derby travel restrictions.
Red & White Army (RAWA) and Newcastle United Supporters Trust (NUST) have written an open letter to the Labour politician, questioning the evidence behind the decision and criticising the lack of consultation with fans.
Sunderland supporters attending December’s Premier League fixture at St James’ Park will be required to travel on official coaches under the bubble arrangements. The trusts want McGuinness to help establish why those restrictions are considered necessary, what risk assessments informed the decision and why supporter representatives were excluded from the process.
Joint letter challenges derby decision
The letter argues that the arrangements risk damaging the region’s reputation for hosting its biggest football occasion. “This is an unprecedented step. It will be the only Premier League fixture subject to bubble restrictions, setting aside the FA Cup anomaly in 2024; it is the first bubble in the long history of the Tyne–Wear derby,” the trusts wrote.
“Such a significant departure demands clear justification. It sends a message that our region cannot safely host its most high-profile football fixture without resorting to the most extreme crowd-control measures available. In short, it’s not a good look for the North East.”
The trusts said neither organisation had been given an opportunity to contribute before the arrangements were decided. “A key concern is that this decision was made without any consultation with supporters. Neither our trust nor any other supporter group was approached, informed, or invited to contribute. Fans only learned of the bubble once it had already been decided. For a measure that affects thousands of ordinary supporters (their travel, costs, and matchday experience), this lack of engagement is unacceptable.”
McGuinness asked to help obtain answers
The letter points to the three arrests made at the previous derby and Northumbria Police’s praise for the behaviour of the overwhelming majority of supporters. It asks whether there have been changes in supporter behaviour, police resources or intelligence to justify the restrictions.
“Without transparency, supporters cannot understand why such a restrictive measure is now deemed necessary,” the trusts wrote. “Bubble matches punish every supporter for the actions of a tiny minority and significantly alter the matchday experience for thousands who have done nothing wrong.”
Addressing McGuinness directly, they added: “Kim, supporters across the region need clarity. We are asking for your support in helping us obtain answers to the questions fans rightly expect to be addressed, as so far we have not been provided with the information from the SAG, Police or the Clubs.”
The trusts also asked whether both clubs endorsed the arrangements. Sunderland have already publicly expressed disagreement with the decision and requested greater transparency.
Supporters offer to work with authorities
RAWA and NUST stressed that their challenge did not diminish the importance of public safety. “We are not asking for safety risks to be ignored. We are asking for decisions to be proportionate, evidence-based, and made with the involvement of those most affected.
“RAWA and NUST stand ready to work constructively with all authorities to ensure the fixture is safe, well-managed, and worthy of our region. But supporters must be part of the conversation, not informed after the fact. We ask for your support in helping fans understand how and why this decision was reached.”
The Echo’s Europa League coverage is sponsored by Amari Plastics. Covering all of North East England and Cumbria, Amari Plastics launched in 1975 and has built a reputation as the region's leading plastic distributor. During this time, we’ve established strong working relationships with businesses in three main market sectors: sign, display & large format printing, building & construction and industrial & engineering.
Your next Sunderland read: Exclusive: Kevin Phillips throws support behind 'brilliant' Regis Le Bris amid recent Sunderland form dip