I followed Jewison Bennette's Sunderland career closely - here's why I think it didn't work out in the end

Sunderland youngster Jewison Bennette is closing in on a move to the Ukrainian top tier

Jewison Bennette’s imminent exit for LNZ Cherkasy reflects a recognition from all parties that two-and-a-half years on from his arrival on Wearside, there now remains little prospect of the Costa Rican turning his undoubted promise into regular contributions.

In such circumstances, it’s often tempting to try and look for an event or a singular reason why things didn’t work out, a moment in time that tells the story. The reality is often very different, and Bennette’s frustrations tell a far more simpler tale of the challenges of recruitment and the ruthless competitiveness of football even at a club now renowned for its faith in youth.

If Bennette does indeed depart from Ukraine on a permanent deal, as now appears more likely than not, then he will have been from start to finish a character thought of very warmly behind the scenes at the Academy of Light, his down-to-earth and upbeat nature best summed by the time he went viral for simply hopping on a bus and heading home with supporters after a game.

What Sunderland were never quite able to manage was to harness that explosive speed and dribbling ability that at one stage seemed to herald the arrival of a future star. Though Sunderland’s 3-0 away at Reading is now best remembered for that team goal, the night the team’s last striker got injured but Tony Mowbray’s side really arrived - Bennette’s debut from the bench was at the time every bit as exciting. Over and over again the then 18-year-old just kept dropping that shoulder and surging past his opposite number. Days later he would score a late equaliser at Vicarage Road against a Watford side still at that stage packed with parachute-payment talent and widely fancied to challenge. Mowbray enthused about Bennette’s talent and predicted that he was about to surprise his fair share of Championship full backs.

It wouldn’t be long until Bennette flew out to represent Costa Rica at the World Cup, but on Wearside his progress had been relatively slow. The main issue behind the scenes was the language barrier; Bennette arrived in the UK with little English and that remained largely the case in the year or so that followed. Understandably, it created a significant challenge in integrating the youngster into the dressing room but most significantly in getting across the level of tactical detail required for him to start games on a regular basis. Sunderland recruited heavily from abroad in that campaign, but many of the players they signed benefited from joining a dressing room where there were a number fluent in French. Those players were able to settle far easier as a result, with Bennette at one stage the only Spanish-speaking player at the club. Sunderland on occasions brought in Julio Arca to help and Bennette continued to enjoy fairly regular cameos from the bench, without ever really pushing Jack Clarke for a place in the XI.

Bennette’s first season was brought to an early conclusion by a shoulder injury, while Clarke began to blossom as one of the most dangerous wide forwards in the entire division. By the start of the 2023/24 season, he had become one of the first names on the teamsheet and taking him out of the side as Sunderland looked to get a play-off push up and running became unthinkable.

Bennette became caught between appearing on the bench and hoping for some late minutes, and playing U21 games where he could at least stay match sharp and better protect his international ambitions. A January loan move became something of a no-brainer but the switch to Aris in the Greek top division was the wrong one for all concerned. Bennette would later give an eye-opening interview in which he detailed the problems he encountered, the upshot being that he played only two games in his time there. To say it was less than ideal preparation for forcing his way into contention at the start of this season would be an understatement.

While Clarke’s future was up in the air throughout pre-season, Bennette was no longer the obvious player in waiting. Right from the early weeks training, the word behind the scenes was that Romaine Mundle was the player who looked to have taken the biggest leap over the summer. Régis Le Bris was suitably impressed, and a standout display in a friendly at Bradford City cemented his place in the pecking order.

The season began with Bennette again dropping into the U21s for regular game time, but by now Tommy Watson was making an inarguable case for senior recognition. A back injury had meant some frustration in the early stages of 2023/24, but he finished the season in stunning form as the U21s surged to the Premier League play-off final. He picked up exactly where he left off, meaning Bennette often had to settle for a place at left-back.

There was almost a deadline-day loan to Charlton Athletic, a move which fell through at the very last minute with time running out to finalise the details. Bennette was now not featuring in the U21 side, with fitness issues cited as the reason. A parting of ways looked the best option, giving Bennette the opportunity to kickstart his career. It was in the weeks that followed that Cherkasy entered the picture.

Still just 20, Bennette still has time firmly on his side and there’s no reason why he can’t go on to have a hugely successful career in the game. His time at Sunderland simply underlines that there are no guarantees in football and in recruitment. If there is a lesson, it’s probably that creating the right environment for a player to thrive is every bit as important as ability.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice