Phil Smith's Sunderland AFC player ratings: Jon McLaughlin 'exceptional' but how did Will Grigg perform?

Will Grigg made his Sunderland debut but he couldn't inspire a win at Oxford United, the Black Cats having to settle for a point.

Jimmy Dunne headed Sunderland in front in the 34th minute from a Grant Leadbitter corner but they couldn't hold on, Marcus Browne scoring the equaliser in the 87th minute following an assist by ex-Sunderland forward Jerome Sinclair. Phil Smith's player ratings below:

Jimmy Dunne celebrates his goal. Getty Images.placeholder image
Jimmy Dunne celebrates his goal. Getty Images.
Another exceptional display of goalkeeping. A string of excellent saves looked like it might prove to be the difference for Sunderland. Result would have been worse without him. 9placeholder image
Another exceptional display of goalkeeping. A string of excellent saves looked like it might prove to be the difference for Sunderland. Result would have been worse without him. 9
Struggled against Jordan Graham in the early stages but the Wolves loanee faded in the second half as the Welshman came through a tough challenge. 6placeholder image
Struggled against Jordan Graham in the early stages but the Wolves loanee faded in the second half as the Welshman came through a tough challenge. 6
Distribution was very poor on his return to the side but fought well on a difficult afternoon. 6placeholder image
Distribution was very poor on his return to the side but fought well on a difficult afternoon. 6
His first Sunderland goal was just one part of a superb showing. Battled brilliantly in the air and made some vital covering challenges. Possible fouled in build up to equalising goal. 7placeholder image
His first Sunderland goal was just one part of a superb showing. Battled brilliantly in the air and made some vital covering challenges. Possible fouled in build up to equalising goal. 7
Quality in the final third was not quite as good as usual and he was beaten occasionally by Gavin Whyte, whose end product was very poor. 6placeholder image
Quality in the final third was not quite as good as usual and he was beaten occasionally by Gavin Whyte, whose end product was very poor. 6
Showed real experience and maturity at the base of midfield. Set piece delivery was a major upgrade and forced the opening goal. 6placeholder image
Showed real experience and maturity at the base of midfield. Set piece delivery was a major upgrade and forced the opening goal. 6
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice