Major update on new homes for long-lost Sunderland pub after developers' controversial plans blocked
Plans to build more than a dozen bungalows on a former Sunderland pub site are due to go before councillors for decision next week.
Sunderland City Council’s Planning and Highways Committee will discuss an application for a parcel of land near the Pennywell shopping centre in the city’s St Anne’s ward.
The site at Portsmouth Road once housed The Eagle public house but has sat vacant for decades since the pub’s demolition in the mid-1990s.
-Credit-LDRS.jpg?crop=3:2,smart&trim=&width=640&quality=65)

Applicant MCC Homes is seeking permission for “13 one-bedroom bungalows” on the site with associated landscaping, access, bin storage and parking.
It also noted that MCC Homes have a “successful track record in delivering high-quality homes for adult social care” and said the firm “works closely with local authorities and social housing providers to deliver homes that not only meet essential housing standards but also promote well-being and stability.”
Those behind the bungalow scheme said the plans would “help to meet local housing demand” while “supporting economic stability and enhancing the attractiveness of the area”.
An ‘economic statement’ submitted to council officials added the development “aligns with Sunderland City Council’s housing strategy by increasing the availability of high-quality, accessible bungalows suitable for elderly residents and individuals with mobility challenges.”
The bungalow scheme follows previous plans from the same applicant for “supported temporary housing for 12 single males” on the site, which the council confirmed would be for “vulnerable people who need support and a safe place to live while they look to secure a new home.”
The councillors had raised concerns about the consultation process and the “unsuitable” site location, due to its “proximity to so many vulnerable groups”, including a school and a nursery.
Meanwhile, members of the public raised concerns about the building being an “inappropriate use” in an area close to schools and community buildings, as well as noting the visual impact of high walls and concerns about the development creating anti-social behaviour, noise and safeguarding issues.


Several reasons for refusal were given by the council, including the visual impact of a proposed wall and gated access, the development impacting the “amenity of existing and future residents, creating social tensions which cannot be adequately mitigated” and the plans “introducing residential accommodation to house vulnerable adults into an area which is already a hotspot for crime and antisocial behaviour.”
During a council public consultation on new plans for bungalows on the same site, no representations were submitted.
Council planners, in a committee report published ahead of a decision-making meeting next week, have recommended the bungalows plan for approval.
It was noted that the development was based in a “sustainable location, with good access to public transport links” and would “contribute to the residential offer within the area”, as well as providing “an acceptable density of development”.
Council planners also noted the plans would “contribute to meeting affordable housing needs”, with 15 per cent of the development expected to be secured as affordable housing via a legal agreement.
The council committee report adds: “Subject to the compliance with recommended conditions it is considered that the proposed development would be of an acceptable design and have no harmful visual impacts when viewed from the public domain.
“The council’s environmental health officer has raised no objections to the proposed development subject to conditions relating to glazing and ventilation, and the construction environmental management plan.
“Subject to compliance with these conditions, it is considered that the proposed development would have no unacceptable impacts on the amenity of the occupiers of existing dwellings in the vicinity of the application site including during the construction process.
“It is also considered that the proposed development would afford future occupiers of the bungalows with an acceptable standard of amenity.
“Subject to the discharge of and compliance with recommended conditions, it is considered that the proposed development would have no unacceptable impacts on highway and pedestrian safety or in relation to flooding / drainage and contamination.
“It would have no unacceptable impacts in relation to ecology, subject to conditions to mitigate and compensate for impact on biodiversity and to provide biodiversity enhancements, and subject to a financial contribution for habitat regulations assessment mitigation (in relation to European designated sites along the coast) being secured via a Section 106 legal agreement.
“It would also have no unacceptable impacts in relation to greenspace, subject to a financial contribution for improvements to alternative open space within the St Anne’s ward, being secured via a Section 106 legal agreement.”
Those behind the bungalow scheme previously said the residential development would “significantly enhance the built environment from the previously vacant plot of land”.
It was argued that the plans would “uplift the local landscape, contributing to a more attractive and desirable neighbourhood, which can lead to increased property values and further private sector investment in the area”.
The applicant’s economic statement added: “The development will foster a sense of community by providing housing tailored to the needs of individuals seeking independent living solutions.
“Improved housing quality and a well- planned layout will contribute to the well-being of future residents, supporting local social cohesion and integration.
“With new residents moving into the area, there will be a positive impact on local businesses and services, such as shops, healthcare facilities, and public transport.
“The increased demand will support the sustainability and growth of local enterprises, reinforcing Pennywell’s economic resilience.”
A previous design and access statement from developers noted MCC Homes purchased the land in 2021 and “has been actively working with the local authority to develop a scheme to provide the required accommodation to meet community needs.”
Developers added that, subject to planning permission being granted, the bungalow scheme would be an “18-month development” providing both direct employment and indirect employment in the wider supply chain.
Councillors on the Planning and Highways Committee will discuss and vote on the plans at a meeting on December 15, 2025, at City Hall.
The meeting is scheduled to take place from 5.30pm and will be open to the public.
For more information on the planning application, visit Sunderland City Council’s planning portal website and search reference: 25/00488/FUL
For the latest public notices from your area, please visit: https://publicnoticeportal.uk/