I was wrongly told I needed my arm amputated and I now want answers from deregistered surgeon
“I’m now in so much more pain and I can no longer do the things I used to be able to do, like painting or just brushing my hair - I’m not bothered about money, I just want answers”
Warning - contains a distressing image
The words of Georgia Sprago who has been left shocked that the surgeon who operated on her as a teenager and who she saw as “almost like an uncle” is having his procedures investigated as part of a patient recall.


Georgia, now 28, was under the care of consultant orthopaedic surgeon Leslie Irwin from the age of 14, and had five operations on her dominant right wrist at Sunderland Royal Hospital from 2012 until his retirement in 2022.
She was referred to Mr Irwin by her GP after developing pain in her right wrist as a result Ehlers Danlos syndrome (EDS), which affects mobility in joints.


Following her first wrist operation in 2012, to tighten the tendon in her wrist, Georgia began to experience excruciating pain. In the following years, Georgia went on to undergo a bone graft, wrist fusion surgery and the insertion of metal work – but continued to suffer ongoing pain and decreasing mobility.
She said: “There’s a huge difference in the level of pain and mobility I now have. Before the surgeries I used to love to paint and cook and I could do normal things like brushing my hair. I’m right handed and now I can’t even hold a cup of tea and I’m in constant pain - much worse than it used to be.
“I’ve also now been told the bones in my forearm are dislocating from where Mr Irwin fused my wrist. My doctor who deals with my EDS said my condition would deteriorate in time, but it shouldn’t have happened anywhere near as quickly or to the extent it has.”
Georgia feels both herself and her mam were not made fully aware of the risks of operating on a patient with EDS.
She added: “Mr Irwin said that all surgery comes with a risk, but I’ve since found out from speaking with medical experts, including my EDS doctor, that surgeries on someone with my condition comes with a much greater risk.”
It was was after her third surgery in 2018 that Mr Irwin hit Georgia with the bombshell that he may have to amputate her wrist - a procedure Georgia says her new consultant has said should “never have been suggested”.
She said: “My third operation involved removing the first layer of bones from my wrist.
“Following this operation the pain got a lot worse. I was waking up during the night in excruciating pain. I assumed I was unlucky and it was down to a deterioration in my condition. I trusted everything Mr Irwin said. He was so nice, and almost like an uncle.
“It was after this operation that he said I needed to prepare myself for possibly needing an amputation, but then five minutes later said he wanted to first try fusing my wrist.
“After Mr Irwin retired in 2022, the first thing I asked my new consultant was whether I needed an amputation and she said this should never have been suggested as an option.
“I was just so relived I wasn’t going to lose my arm that I never really thought about anything else and just began to get on with my life.”


That was until she read the article in the Echo confirming that Spire Washington Hospital were recalling patients of Mr Irwin to “review their care and offer support”.
After being contacted by the hospital, a number of Mr Irwin’s patients contacted medical law specialists Slater and Gordon, who confirmed a “significant” number of people came forward following the story.
It was also confirmed a number of patients were NHS patients who had been operated on by Mr Irwin during the same period when he was also working as a consultant at Sunderland Royal Hospital.
One of those was Georgia.
She said: “When I saw his picture I said to my mam ‘I’m sure that’s Mr Irwin’. After I read the account of one of the patients it sounded so similar to my case and I just burst into tears.
“Since then, I’ve had this battle in my head about him being potentially responsible for what has happened with my arm and a sadness that someone who I had grown so close to could have done this.”
Like other patients, Georgia’s case has now been taken on by Slater and Gordon.
She said: “I’m not really interested in money, I just want answers. Should he have carried out all these surgeries knowing I had EDS? Would my arm be in better state if it had been left?
“I just need to know.”
Following the patient recalls by Spire Washington Hospital we contacted Spire Healthcare who confirmed Mr Irwin had practised at the hospital between 2001 and 2023.
They confirmed he was suspended in August 2023 and they withdrew his practising privileges in September 2024 - though they did not specify the reasons why.
A spokesperson said: “We are currently reviewing specific procedures that were provided to a select cohort of patients of Mr Leslie Irwin, a consultant orthopaedic surgeon who previously practised at Spire Washington Hospital.
“We are in direct contact with all relevant patients to review their care and offer support. The review is being run in accordance with NHS England’s National Quality Board: Recall Framework, which Spire Healthcare helped to develop.
“If any Spire Washington patients have questions about the care provided by Mr Irwin, they can call 0191 720 3031 or email [email protected] and a member of the dedicated review team will call them back.”
We also contacted South Tyneside and Sunderland NHS Foundation Trust who govern the city’s hospital.
A spokesperson said: “We have liaised with Spire to understand the scale of their patient recall and to help inform our next steps as a Trust.
“We are currently working through the detail of which patients we may need to review and will contact those people directly and as a matter of priority.
“Mr Irwin retired from South Tyneside and Sunderland NHS Foundation Trust in May 2022.”
After being contacted by the Echo about Georgia’s case the Trust said their statement is unchanged. Georgia has not yet been contacted by Sunderland Royal Hospital.
The General Medical Council confirmed “Dr Leslie Irwin is no longer registered, having relinquished his registration”, adding “we only have powers to investigate doctors who are GMC registered”.
Slater and Gordon is holding an in-person legal clinic for anyone with concerns about the care they have received from Leslie Irwin. It will take place on Thursday, February 19, from 10am to 2pm, at the Beacon of Light.
Email [email protected] for more information.
We also contacted the Royal College of Surgeons who directed us to contact South Tyneside and Sunderland NHS Foundation Trust and Spire Washington Hospital.
