Appeal lodged after plans to transform ex-Sunderland offices into student flats are refused
Plans for 30 student flats at a former city law office site will now be decided by a Government-appointed planning inspector after developers challenged a council refusal of the scheme.
An appeal has been lodged against Sunderland City Council’s decision to block proposals for Mowbray Villas, in Ashbrooke, which was previously home to Sweeney Miller Law before the firm’s relocation.


Plans submitted last year said the scheme would bring a long-vacant office building back into productive use and would support students wanting to live within south Sunderland.
Yet officers had recommended the plan be refused as it clashed with planning policy.
They explained: “Student accommodation numbers need to be managed in line with projected student numbers to ensure the city does not end up with an oversupply of accommodation, which cannot be easily converted to other uses”.
Officers added the development was “located outside of the urban core” and that “no details have been provided to demonstrate there are no suitable and available sites to accommodate the proposed development within the urban core, or, that there is an additional need for student accommodation in this location”.
They argued that student accommodation was the only viable use for Mowbray Villas and would secure its future and that refusing plans could lead to “continued vacancy, accelerated decay and potential demolition.”
But the comments were not enough to convince councillors who voted to refuse the plan.
The applicant has since lodged an appeal and a planning inspector will be appointed by the Government to rule on the matter.
An appeal statement from developers claims “substantial quantitative and qualitative evidence” supporting their case was submitted during the original application.
The appeal statement said that the plan’s location outside the urban core by a “limited extent” would be outweighed by the benefits of the scheme.
The appeal will be determined via written representations and the Planning Inspectorate will publish an update once a decision has been made.