The Sunderland-born welterweight was dropped twice by the Russian in the sixth round before trainer Adam Booth threw in the towel.
Reacting to the fight on the Sunderland Echo’s Facebook page, many fight fans questioned the wisdom of Kelly’s promoter Eddie Hearn in matching against such a strong opponent in just his 12th professional fight.
Avanesyan, 32, once defeated hall of fame fighter and three-weight world champion Shane Mosely, and is now knocking on the door for a world title shot after retaining his European strap.
Supercomputer predicts final Championship table - including surprise finishes for Sunderland, Middlesbrough, QPR, Sheffield United and co
Championship transfer news: Interest in £22million man, setback for Arsenal loanee plus Norwich reports
Sunderland AFC transfer news: Cats take 'brilliant' ex-Manchester United and Burnley midfielder on trial
Sunderland AFC transfer gossip: Cats in 'final stages' of deal for 18-y/o eight-cap international winger
Sheffield United suffer injury blow ahead of Sunderland game with 264 goal striker potentially sidelined
The reaction to Kelly and his performance, however, was overwhelmingly positive from the people of Sunderland.
Here’s what you said on Facebook:
Trevor Lynn: “Proud of him for stepping up fought well but other boxer was more experienced.”
Mick Prescott: “He'll bounce back there's no shame in losing to a world-class fighter.”
Martin Cutter: “He’s massive for welterweight maybe he should move up a weight class. He has all the skill but by the 5th round he was gassed. And I can’t see him competing with the top welterweights like Spence, Crawford, Thurman etc.”
Shaun Glenwright: “A fight that was maybe too soon for him and one he will learn from. He will be back.”
Linda Blackwell: “Still proud of you.”
Micky Heskett: “Win lose or draw city should be proud of him.”
Graham Hill: “Shame. Was a big step up. I don't understand the tactics at all though. Trying to back Ava up was ridiculous, never ever going to work. Josh doesn't carry enough pop. Should have used his jab more and stuck and moved. Got dragged into a fight and got blown out and gassed far too quickly. Back to the drawing board."
Ian Wilkinson: “Another fighter used as a pawn by the Hearn.”
Liam Peverley: “Too soon for me being pushed, Eddie Hearn only doing it cause he gets views.”
Joe Jones: “Still win lose or draw we are proud of him.”