Phil Bardsley's powerful free-kick gave Sunderland an early lead but after Tim Cahill headed the home side level it was a tale of almost unbroken pressure from David Moyes's men in this sixth-round tie.
Unfortunately, Everton were victorious in the reply at the Stadium of Light. But where did that Sunderland team end up? Here, we take a look!
13. SUB 2: Sotirios Kyrgiakos
Retired in 2014 after a stint with Sydney Olympic | Getty Images Photo: Stu Forster
14. SUB 3: Matthew Kilgallon
Currently with Indian side Hyderabad FC. | Getty Images Photo: Stu Forster
15. SUB 4: Ahmed Elmohamady
The Egyptian winger is back in the Premier League under the stewardship of Dean Smith at Aston Villa. | Getty Images Photo: AFP
16. SUB 5: David Meyler
David Meyler announced his retirement from professional football aged just 30 after a series of injury problems. | Getty Images Photo: Jamie McDonald