Phil Bardsley's powerful free-kick gave Sunderland an early lead but after Tim Cahill headed the home side level it was a tale of almost unbroken pressure from David Moyes's men in this sixth-round tie.
Unfortunately, Everton were victorious in the reply at the Stadium of Light. But where did that Sunderland team end up? Here, we take a look!
5. Michael Turner
The defender joined League One team Southend United, making 65 appearances and scoring five goals before his release at the end of the 2018-19 season. | Getty Images Photo: David Price
6. Jack Colback
After his move to local rivals Newcastle United, Jack Colback has seen himself frozen out by consecutive managers in Rafa Benitez and Steve Bruce. Wasn’t given a squad number this season | Getty Images Photo: Clive Brunskill
7. Craig Gardner
The midfielder, who cost Sunderland a whopping £8million, now turns out for Birmingham City in the Championship | Getty Images Photo: Stu Forster
8. Seb Larsson
Back in 2018, Larsson signed for Swedish club AIK, winning topflight for the twelfth time in the club's history in his first season with the club. | Getty Images Photo: Laurence Griffiths