The strange state of play at Sunderland explored as Lee Johnson and Kristjaan Speakman's revolution begins amid Kyril Louis-Dreyfus takeover wait

In the build-up to Sunderland's league fixture at MK Dons, Lee Johnson had prepared a video for his players.
Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now

It featured some of the goals they had scored in his nascent tenure; goals specifically selected because they highlighted the speed and bravery in transition that he hopes to make the hallmark of his side.

Tongue firmly in cheek, Johnson noted that with the right choice of music, the whole thing could be quite emotional.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Sunderland's head coach knows as well as anyone that progress since his arrival has not been linear. Saturday's frustrating draw captured that perfectly. There was some quick, exciting football on show, particularly in a strong second-half showing. There was also a 20-minute period where the Black Cats looked like they would be entirely overwhelmed.

Sporting Director Kristjaan SpeakmanSporting Director Kristjaan Speakman
Sporting Director Kristjaan Speakman

Through decent stretches of games they have looked laboured, constrained by many of the same shortcomings that affected both of Johnson’s predecessors.

There are many good reasons for this.

For one, Johnson has been tasked with implementing a new playing philosophy from which everything stems from a co-ordinated and high-intensity pressing game.

To introduce this with consistent results requires above all else time on the training ground. This has been virtually non-existent, due initially to the COVID-19 outbreak that forced the closing of the Academy of Light, and then the fixture pile-up that has inevitably followed.

Head coach Lee JohnsonHead coach Lee Johnson
Head coach Lee Johnson
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

It also requires a squad built specifically to execute it's demands, and here it seems clear that Johnson will need a summer overhaul to fully realise his vision.

With the number of players out of contract at the end of the campaign exceeding 20, this feels as if it will be the vital juncture in Johnson's revolution.

January is a notoriously difficult window to begin with, never mind when accounting for the difficulties caused by the pandemic and the hugely controversial salary cap rules introduced last summer.

Even then, it was encouraging to see the business done fit in with Johnson's stated vision to make his squad sharper and more attacking.

Sunderland fans are waiting for confirmation of the takeover led by Kyril Louis-DreyfusSunderland fans are waiting for confirmation of the takeover led by Kyril Louis-Dreyfus
Sunderland fans are waiting for confirmation of the takeover led by Kyril Louis-Dreyfus
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Add into the mix the increased gametime for Aiden McGeady and Jack Diamond, and it is possible to feel optimistic about a vision starting to be realised even if the football remains not wholly convincing from game to game.

This, though, is the odd thing about Sunderland's so far very velvet revolution: no one can really talk about it.

Key figures can vaguely discuss the long-term aspirations and direction of travel, but the final confirmation of the takeover led by Kyril Louis-Dreyfus remains elusive.

Sunderland announced on Christmas Eve that a deal had been agreed for Louis-Dreyfus to become the majority shareholder, and that they hoped it would be confirmed midway through January.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

That we are still waiting for that is not necessarily cause for concern in itself.

Even in that initial statement, Sunderland noted the unique demands the EFL are facing at the moment, an early warning that there could be no guarantee of a swift resolution.

The tests approving new ownership have quite rightly been significantly tightened and there seems to remain a sense of calm and confidence that the deal will be ratified as planned.

Johnson has been totally becalmed when pressed on the matter in his media briefings, confident that everything behind the scenes suggests all is on track.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Despite the initially awkward exchanges on his arrival, when the deal’s final negotiations meant he could not discuss it in public, he is now happy to cite the pending takeover as one reason for optimism when looking to the future.

That there is an edginess in the fanbase is entirely understandable, when the current ownership group have twice been on the brink of selling the club before collapse (though admittedly, it has never got as far as an official club statement).

It is widely known that Johnson’s arrival was ultimately Sporting Director Kristjaan Speakman’s call, who in turn arrived as the central figure in what will be a major change in direction under Louis-Dreyfus.

Speakman has been tasked with modernising all aspects of the club’s footballing operation, from first-team recruitment to a rebuild of the academy structures.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

There have already been some encouraging signs, with many behind the scenes impressed with his early contributions. Above all else, the daily presence and attention he brings to the role is welcome after the first two years of the Madrox era.

There was one transfer deal last week that spoke to a significantly improved structure in place.

The deal to loan out Elliot Embleton was an initially divisive one, and a surprise given that Sunderland’s stance at the beginning of the window was that the 21-year-old would be going nowhere.

The statement confirming his switch to Blackpool offered an immediate and measured explanation from Speakman, confirming that the club had made a move to protect their asset by extending his contract for a year.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Johnson offered his assessment a day later and what initially looked like a confusing move began to have an ongoing logic.

Debate will continue over whether it was the right call (and the ongoing fear here is that creativity in central areas still looks to be lacking from this squad), but it is at least one that has been made with due care and attention.

Generally, though, Speakman’s public profile has been low-key. He has spoken eloquently and convincingly about his brief on the club’s podcast but there is little doubt that confirmation of Louis-Dreyfus’ takeover is going to be key to his work.

It leaves both he and Johnson in a curious position as they start out on what they hope will be a long and fruitful transformation of the team.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

When Phil Parkinson was appointed as Manager, it was made abundantly clear that the one and only goal was promotion.

Johnson is expected to deliver that, too, and yet the suggestions from all key figures behind the scenes is that there will be key other metrics that he is expected to perform well in.

He will live and die by results as all head coaches and managers do, but he will also be judged on his ability to introduce a defined style of play and within that, to improve academy and senior players to the point where they become major assets for the club.

Development is at the heart of the Louis-Dreyfus strategy which is why Speakman was given a job that is often handed to someone with a background primarily in recruitment.

These are long-term goals, requiring time and patience.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The takeover makes the debate around that challenging because it is obvious that in order to succeed, both will require significant investment that seems unlikely to be forthcoming without Louis-Dreyfus.

Speakman, for example, needs to rebuild a recruitment team almost entirely from scratch and over six months after his departure, Paul Reid has still not been replaced as Academy Manager.

A scepticism will remain until the i’s are dotted and the t’s crossed because so much of this new vision runs directly at odds with the experience of the last two-and-a-half years, where short-termism has defined just every move of the Madrox tenure.

You can already begin to see Sunderland working towards creating a quicker, more athletic side, bringing down the average age of the squad and the starting XI.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

All of this is long overdue and yet for now, many supporters remain understandably concerned that the project ultimately is still in the hands of a regime they no longer trust.

Welcome change may well have begun, but the most important piece of the puzzle is yet to be put in place.

A message from the Football Clubs Editor

Our aim is to provide you with the best, most up-to-date and most informative Sunderland AFC coverage 365 days a year.

This depth of coverage costs, so to help us maintain the high-quality reporting that you are used to, please consider taking out a subscription to our new sports-only package here.

Your support is much appreciated. Richard Mennear, Football Clubs Editor