'Tempted to think...' - Sunderland writer Phil Smith on dropping Eliezer Mayenda and the 4-4-2 debate

The latest episode of the Sunderland Echo’s The Roar podcast is out now.

It’s a debate that has been simmering on Wearside for most of the season - should Sunderland play with a 4-3-3 or 4-4-2 formation?

The Black Cats have deployed both at various points this term, but after Eliezer Mayenda scored a match-winning brace against Sheffield Wednesday on Friday evening, Sunderland writers Phil Smith and James Copley have once again been discussing the possibility of a change in shape in this week’s edition of The Roar podcast.

You can watch the full episode here, or listen on Spotify here, and with Sunderland facing two home matches in quick succession against Cardiff City and Preston North End over the coming days, it is a pertinent question that Regis Le Bris will no doubt be weighing up too...

The advantages and disadvantages of Sunderland playing 4-4-2

Addressing the possibility of a change in shape, SAFC chief writer Phil Smith said: “I thought that Sheffield United game was a great performance, but a lot of the other times that Sunderland have played 4-4-2, I've not loved it, to be honest. I think you do lose so much in midfield. And I think now that he's had the opportunity to rest Chris Rigg, now that Alan Browne's got 60-odd minutes under his belt - and I thought looked canny against Sheffield Wednesday, given how it was literally his first competitive minutes for three months - I'm tempted to think that he [Le Bris] probably won't go to 4-4-2.

“I think it was interesting... I can't remember which game it was, but it was probably about a month, maybe six weeks ago now, I asked Le Bris about going to 4-4-2, and I asked him about Mayenda and how difficult it was given how well Mayenda was doing not picking him in the team. And to be honest, Le Bris was like, ‘Not really, it's perfect, he's 19. We need players who can make an impact off the bench’.

“Let's be fair as well, we've criticised Le Bris at times over the season for not having game-changing subs, and Mayenda is one. It's the perfect situation, he's learning from a top Championship striker in Wilson Isidor, he's playing, getting minutes, he's changing the game for us, giving us something different. So I'm inclined to think that he'll probably be quite happy with how it is at the moment, where Mayenda starts the odd game, comes off the bench pretty much every game and brings some fresh legs from the bench. I don't have a major issue with that.

“I think you could bring Rigg back in and start on Saturday [against Cardiff City], given that he's had a bit of a breather, you could start with Browne. I wouldn't be furious personally if Mayenda didn't start on Saturday. I can understand why he [Le Bris] wants to keep things as stable as he can and ultimately you do need players who can change the game off the bench. So I don't think we should see it as a snub on Saturday, if the team is dropped and Mayenda is on the bench. I think that Le Bris’ argument is a fair one.”

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

Can Sunderland bench Eliezer Mayenda after he scored twice vs Sheffield Wednesday?

In response to that particular question, Phil continued: “I think you can. I don't think Le Bris works in that way. I think he just works on what's the best thing to do for the next game. I don't think he's particularly bothered about upsetting players. I think if he thinks it's right to bring Isidor back in and bring Rigg back in, I think he'll just calmly explain his decision and I don't think he'll be too bothered whether it upsets anyone.

“The honest answer is I don't know. But if you put me on the spot, I think he'll probably just stick with 4-3-3 for Saturday, I think, and use Mayenda as an impact substitute. But we'll see. If he feels that Isidor still could do with another rest, maybe he'll just stick as it is with Mayenda. I think that's the positive here, that we've got the option now to be a bit more flexible in selection.

“And I think the nice thing as well, the important thing about getting that result on Friday is it just gives everyone a little bit of breathing space. I think we should be looking to win every game because the top two isn't gone yet. But also I think had you lost on Friday, there would be this sense of we need to get a result here against Cardiff. Of course, they do need to win, but it just feels like... it's a bit of a relief for everyone, I think. And that, I think, strengthens Sunderland’s position a lot going into these couple of home games.”

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice