Why Lutsharel Geertruida is expected to leave Sunderland this summer explained after stellar Man Utd showing

Sunderland have an option to turn Geertruida’s loan from RB Leipzig into a permanent deal this summer

Had you told a neutral watching Sunderland v Manchester United that the home side's right back looked almost certain to leave the club this summer, they might well have assumed it was because of transfer interest from an elite club.

It was credit to Lutsharel Geertruida's professionalism and quality that after another frustrating few weeks on the sidelines, he was able to produce a sterling display. Had his effort midway through the second half been a matter inches to the right, he would have rightly walked away with the plaudits as the matchwinner in one of Sunderland's most impressive results of the campaign.

Yet when Sky Sports in Germany had reported 24 hours earlier that Geertruida would depart and return to RB Leipzig this summer, most likely then moving on again in a permanent deal, there was disappointment but little surprise on Wearside. For what it's worth, Régis Le Bris reiterated in his post-match press conference that no final decision had been made and that would remain the case until after the campaign. It's a sensible and pragmatic approach to take - Geertruida's loan will not officially expire until later in the summer and football is a volatile industry where things can change very quickly. Were there to be unexpected movement in Sunderland's squad early in the summer window ahead of the World Cup, maybe things would change.

However, those reports did not come from nowhere and sources indicate it is now considered highly unlikely that Sunderland trigger the option to make his loan permanent for a fee reported to be in the region of £20 million. So why not? Behind the scenes, the view is that both parties likely want to assess their options. This has, make no mistake, been a very successful loan. Geertruida has made 28 appearances across all competitions, played in a number of positions and contributed to Sunderland achieving their primary goal and then moving beyond it. He has brought experience, quality and professionalism to a squad initially short on top-level experience.

The issue is that he still isn't a clear first choice in a single position and crucially, there's every chance that doesn't change heading into next season. Though he has succeeded in a large number of roles over the course of the season, the evidence of those 28 games is that his very strongest positions are right back or right centre-back. Geertruida would grace just about any Premier League team at right back, but so too would Nordi Mukiele. Mukiele has been exceptional this season in that role, and is one of the most important figures in the Sunderland dressing room. Alongside him, Dan Ballard would be many fans' pick for player of the season. Ballard signed a new long-term contract earlier this season, and is a massive part of the club's plans moving forward. While Geertruida's last three performances in a Sunderland shirt have been top drawer, he arguably didn't quite do enough earlier in the campaign to force his way past either of those two players at the time.

When you assess Sunderland's squad moving into next season, there is a strong argument that it's the left side of defence that requires more urgent attention. Omar Alderete and Reinildo have been exceptional this season, but with Dennis Cirkin's contract up this summer there will be very little depth behind them as things stand. On the other flank, Geertruida's strongest, Trai Hume offers another option. Hume's consistency is such that he has played more minutes than any other outfield player in the Premier League for Sunderland this season. He has never let Sunderland down, just like last season, the season before that, and the one-and-a-half before that.

The very valid counter argument at this point is that to go to the next level, Sunderland need depth and competition right across the pitch: at which point you have to probably consider the player's position. While he has a number of appearances under his belt this season, he turns 26 this summer and is approaching peak age. He has spent most of his career starting week in, week out at the top level and retains major international ambitions. Will he be eager to sign up for potentially another campaign waiting for injury, suspension or a loss of form to present him with an opportunity? Ultimately, this is a major decision for both parties and right now there is ultimately too much uncertainty to proceed, particularly given it would be a deal that would take out a chunk of Sunderland's summer budget.

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

From Sunderland's perspective, if they don't trigger the clause as now appears likely then it is a decision that will undoubtedly carry real risk. They will be losing a player of clear Premier League quality from a squad that has often been stretched this season and there will be no guarantee they will be able to source an alternative as good, particularly at the price.

So for now, it's still just a little too soon to be definitively drawing a line under Geertruida's time at the club. His performance against Man Utd will likely mean he will play the next two games, and performances like the one he produced last weekend may yet give pause for thought. Most likely, though, he departs as Sunderland's first major transfer call of the summer. Preparations for the window have been underway for some time as Flo Ghisolfi and his revamped, massively bolstered recruitment department get to work. They will have a plan, only after we see what it looks like will this decision be fully understood.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice