James Copley: Sunderland have a transfer dilemma coming – and getting the timing right is everything
Matty Young has remarkably reached 100 senior appearances at just 19 – but Sunderland face a fascinating decision over when his loan education should end
Matty Young’s reported admirers at Liverpool should probably be viewed as a compliment more than anything else by Sunderland.
The Black Cats have one of the most highly-rated young goalkeepers in the country on their books, tied down until 2030 and developing exactly as they would have hoped. The more interesting question is when that development should stop happening elsewhere.
Young reached 100 senior appearances during Huddersfield Town’s win over Burton Albion at the weekend. He is still only 19. That is a remarkable level of experience for a goalkeeper of his age. Young has already progressed from Darlington to Salford City and now Huddersfield, moving from non-league football into League Two and then League One.
If this season continues positively, the obvious next step would be Championship football. But at some point the loans have to end. That is where Robin Roefs makes the situation more complicated. Roefs has been a revelation since arriving at Sunderland and remains firmly established as Régis Le Bris’ number one. He is also still developing himself.
The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates directly to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.
This is only Roefs’ third season playing regular senior football, which means Sunderland essentially have two young goalkeepers progressing at different stages of the same pathway. In an ideal world, the timelines eventually meet perfectly. Roefs continues to improve, Sunderland eventually receive the sort of offer that makes a sale sensible and Young returns ready to take over.
The problem is working out when that point comes. If Sunderland received a huge offer for Roefs next summer, would Young genuinely be ready to become a Premier League number one at 20 after one season in League One? Probably not. That does not mean Sunderland should have any concerns about his potential. Quite the opposite. But it could indicate they would need a transition season from Melker Ellborg or potentially a stop-gap signing before fully throwing Young in.
Another season, ideally at Championship level, would give Young another significant step up in quality and could leave Sunderland with a 21-year-old goalkeeper already approaching 150 senior appearances. At that point, the conversation changes. There is also an argument that his next move after another loan should not necessarily be straight into Sunderland’s starting XI.
Young already returns to the Academy of Light when his schedule allows, helping maintain his relationship with the club and senior set-up. Eventually, spending a season training alongside Roefs and competing properly within Sunderland’s first-team environment may be just as important as another loan.
That transition needs to be timed carefully. Bring him back too early and Sunderland risk interrupting the momentum he has built by playing every week. Keep sending him away indefinitely, and eventually he will understandably want to know when his opportunity is coming. Young has already made clear what Sunderland means to him.
He is a supporter, his family are Sunderland through and through, and he described being around the club as meaning “everything” when signing his new contract. Liverpool interest therefore does not need to alter Sunderland’s plan. But it does underline why that plan needs to remain convincing. Young’s development so far has been handled extremely well. The difficult decision is no longer whether Sunderland have a potential future first-team goalkeeper. It is deciding exactly when he becomes one.
