Sunderland's strongest starting XI according to the stats experts

The stats experts reveal who would make the cut in Sunderland’s strongest starting eleven.

The latest international break of the season offers an opportunity to reflect on what has been a challenging first three months of the season for Sunderland.

For the first time since 1973, the Black Cats are balancing the demands of competing in European competition alongside the ‘bread and butter’ of trying to impress in the Premier League once again. As it stands in the aftermath of Sunday’s home win against Chelsea, Regis Le Bris’ men are sitting in the relegation zone after that victory against the Blues marked only the second time Sunderland have collected maximum points from a league game this season.

The cup competitions have provided some room for positivity for the Wearside faithful with Sunderland in contention for a place in the last 16 of the Europa League after securing seven points from their first four games of the league phase. There has also progress made in the Carabao Cup with wins against Hull City and Brentford setting up a quarter-final clash at Premier League rivals Crystal Palace next month.

With the FA Cup still on the agenda in the new year, Le Bris will have to manage his squad carefully to ensure he can chase progress on several fronts during the second half of the campaign - but what is the Black Cats strongest starting eleven? We take a look with the help of average match ratings from the stats experts at WhoScored.

Sunderland’s best starting eleven according to the stats experts

Robin Roefs.placeholder image
Robin Roefs. | Getty Images

GK: Robin Roefs - 6.3

RB: Thomas Meunier - 6.9

CB: Nordi Mukiele - 7.4

CB: Dan Ballard - 7.0

LB: Reinildo Mandava - 6.5

CM: Granit Xhaka - 6.7

CM: Jules Ahoka - 6.8

RM: Trai Hume - 6.8

AMC: Enzo Le Fee - 6.8

LM: Nilson Angulo - 6.5

ST: Brian Brobbey - 6.7

Other Sunderland player ratings

Luke O'Nien in Sunderland action.placeholder image
Luke O'Nien in Sunderland action. | Chris Fryatt.

Luke O’Nien - 6.36

Wilson Isidor - 6.26

Chris Rigg - 6.22

Habib Diarra - 6.18

Malick Fofana - 6.18

Chemsdine Talbi - 6.11

Timur Tutierov - 6.06

Romaine Mundle - 6.00

Jocelin Ta Bi - 5.96

Juan Angulo - 5.85

Kevin Danso - 5.60

Omar Alderete - 5.38

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice