Régis Le Bris answers Brian Brobbey refereeing question Sunderland fans have been asking after Man Utd draw

Sunderland fans have been increasingly frustrated with refereeing decisions consistently going against Brian Brobbey

Régis Le Bris says Sunderland have raised their concerns over how Brian Brobbey is treated by referees but said he also feels that the officials have a tough job.

The issue was brought into focus again during Sunderland's 0-0 draw with Manchester United, with the home support and players left frustrated with a number of decisions that went against the 24-year-old. While Le Bris feels the striker can get a raw deal due to his physicality, he was reluctant to criticise Saturday's referee Stuart Attwell.

The Black Cats have made their feelings clear to officials over the course of the season but Le Bris was also quick to note that he had also on this occasion come up against two experienced and skilled opponents.

"We've had the conversation but it's hard to ref Brian," Le Bris said.

"He's not a usual profile [of striker], so probably he needs to be a bit protected at times because it's so physical. He has a specific style of play, I think it's hard to ref Brian at times, I repeat. The defenders in the Premier League are strong and intense. So Manchester United had Maguire on one side and Martinez on the other, who is smaller but so skilled and they're both experienced.

"It's not easy. He's a particular player but overall I think it was fair."

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

Ref Watch duo deliver verdict on Brian Brobbey penalty claim in Man Utd draw

Attwell's decision to award Manchester United a foul in the second half when Brian Brobbey and Luke Shaw grappled inside the penalty area was discussed on Sky Sports’ Ref Watch show.

Former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher felt Brobbey had made the initial foul, and that Attwell was correct.

"I think it's a tough call because it's already started there," he said.

"When you see the first image, Brobbey actually grabs him there and that's what pulls Luke Shaw around because Luke Shaw ends up not facing the ball. So that the argument is there: Well, he's not looking at the ball, he should be looking at the ball [but] he's engaging the player. But he's actually been dragged into that position. So I think Stuart's right there, I think, foul by Brobbey."

Former Premier League striker Jay Bothroyd felt Brobbey was unfortunate to be penalised.

"I mean, I'm looking at that from a forward's point of view," he said.

"And I'm saying to myself, you know, Brobbey is trying to get to where the ball is going. Yes, they're both grappling but then it becomes a point where Shaw is now looking at the ball. And you'll probably say, you know, that's because Brobbey's holding him but Shaw's holding him as well. And these are the kind of situations, I mean, I'm always going to give the forward the benefit of the doubt. But I genuinely think that Shaw, if they're both being fair, Shaw is not going to beat Brobbey in a physical duel. So he has to do everything he can to stop him getting to the ball. But I think that was a wrong decision, I think Brobbey should have been given the benefit of the doubt."

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice