The early Sunderland season player ratings: Standout 8/10s and those starting to find their best form

Sunderland have made a solid start to the campaign but have endured some frustration in the league in particular

It has already been a dramatic start to Sunderland’s historic season, with the Black Cats making progress in two competitions but enduring some frustration in the Premier League.

So who has started well and who has more to offer when the Black Cats return to action later this month? Here we take an early look at how each player has fared to date…

Note: Only players with more than one competitive appearance have been given a rating.

Robin Roefs

Two exceptionally clinical performances from Man City and Arsenal mean it has been at times a tough start to the season for Roefs in terms of replicating last season’s shotstopping heroics, but he continues to impress with his composure and was superb against AZ Alkmaar. 6

Melker Ellborg

Though it wasn’t always straightforward, the goalkeeper came through his first appearance of the campaign and secured a clean sheet in the Carabao Cup win over Hull City. Suffered the disappointment of being left out of the Europa League squad due to the homegrown player restrictions. N/A

Nordi Mukiele

Didn’t get on the pitch at Ipswich due to an injury picked up in pre-season and his intensity and quality was a big miss. Unsurprisingly has been one of Sunderland’s star performers since then, outstanding in the win against Fulham in particular. Simply vital to his team’s prospects. 8.5

Dan Ballard

Took a week or two to really get going but looked firmly back to his best over the last couple of weeks, making the hamstring injury he picked up on international duty last week all the more frustrating. 7

Omar Alderete

Still searching for full match fitness after battling a knee injury at the end of last season and during the World Cup. Hasn’t found his form yet as a result but has shown in the past what he can offer at his best. 5

Kevin Danso

An inspired signing who aside from one error at Man City, has slotted into the side faultlessly and established himself as a key player. Already crucial and on his way to becoming a fan favourite. 8

Luke O’Nien

Tough opening day at Ipswich Town having enjoyed such a strong pre-season and end to 2025/26. Bounced back well in the Carabao Cup and no doubt his time will come again. 5.5

Reinildo

A few excellent performances to help Sunderland get on the board in the Premier and Europa League, but was shown a red card late in the Arsenal game. Solid start on the whole. 6.5

Dayann Methalie

Is being integrated slowly following his move from Toulouse but the signs from his first two appearances were encouraging. Quick and brave on the ball he brings a different dimension to the side, and did well to manage picking up a booking early at Man City. 6

Join the Echo’s WhatsApp SAFC Channel for the latest news, team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join.

Thomas Meunier

Has brought leadership, energy and tactical flexibility. Slotted in seamlessly and already a key player in the squad. 7.5

Trai Hume

Will be frustrated to have lost his place in the Premier League starting XI, but remains a vital part of the squad and has been typically consistent when called upon. 6.5

Granit Xhaka

Hasn’t yet hit the heights of last season after a heavy summer workload, but has still produced some crucial moments and his forward passing remains one of Sunderland’s most dependable routes to goal. 7

Noah Sadiki

Vital to the balance of the side and his consistency in disrupting the opposition and keeping Sunderland moving is hugely impressive. Targeting moe contributions in the final third and it has been a quiet start on that front. 6.5

Enzo Le Fée

Took a couple of weeks to recapture his form from the end of last season but is now showing why he is currently one of the first names on the teamsheet. Producing so many chances for his team mates and working tirelessly off the ball. 7.5

Chris Rigg

It’s been a tough start for Rigg who is struggling for Premier League minutes, but an excellent pre-season and a top showing against Hull City in the cup show he is making progress behind the scenes. 6

Habib Diarra

A hamstring injury means he has only made two brief cameos this season but in that time he helped Sunderland to a vital win at Fulham and showed what a big part he has to play when back fit. It was a genuine statement cameo. N/A

Jules Ahoka

A superb debut against Hull City means that while it is too early to judge, he looks a very smart addition and a huge prospect. N/A

Jocelin Ta Bi

Had a good game against Hull City and has been a standout player in the U21s when he has featured. Has huge potential and a real shame a potential loan move to Burnley fell through. N/A

Nilson Angulo

One goal and one assist is a reasonable start but he perhaps should have had more. To his credit, his work rate is superb and he brings a lot to the side in and out of possession. Growing in stature week by week. 7

Malick Fofana

Hasn’t quite got going yet even if there have been some promising signs in his cameos to date. Lots more to come once he is settled and match fit. 5.5

Chemsdine Talbi

It’s been a disappointing start to the season but not really of his own doing, as he has clearly fallen down the pecking order and had his progress disrupted by a potential move away late in the window. His performance against Hull was outstanding and showed he has probably been unlucky with his playing time. 5

Wilson Isidor

Crucial goal against Fulham and won a penalty against Brentford, showing signs through many of his cameos so far that the club were right to hand him a new deal and cement his place in the squad. 7

Brian Brobbey

Took him a week or two to get going but produced a seriously high level against Arsenal and Man City, which will hopefully kickstart his goalscoring form providing he hasn’t suffered a significant injury on international duty. 7.5

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice