Phil Smith: I watched Sunderland's draw with Man Utd and these were my key conclusions

Sunderland impressed in their draw with Manchester United on Saturday afternoon

Sunderland drew 0-0 with Manchester United at the Stadium of Light on Saturday afternoon.

Phil Smith was there reporting for The Echo and these were his key conclusions…

Sunderland deserved three points and it bodes well for the future

The feeling that this might not be the worst time to play Man Utd, a side perhaps now looking to the summer having secured Champions League football with a win over Liverpool, was bolstered when the team news dropped.

Benjamin Šeško was a significant absentee and though Joshua Zirkzee is a player with significant pedigree in Europe, here he lacked the physicality needed to compete with Omar Alderete. There was no Casemiro in midfield and Bryan Mbeumo, exceptional at Old Trafford in the reverse fixture, was named on the bench. The visitors looked a little flat and most certainly short on the fluidity with which they have often played under Michael Carrick.

While necessary context when assessing Sunderland’s performance, it also shouldn’t take anything away from what was an immensely encouraging showing from Régis Le Bris’s side. It wasn’t just how enjoyable it was to watch their football at times, but that the data firmly backs up the sense that they were the better side. Sunderland generated double Manchester United’s XG, with the visitors only registering a shot on target in stoppage time at the end of the second half. The Black Cats had ten shots in the first half for the first time this season, and over 20 touches in the opposition box in the first half alone. That Senne Lammens was clearly Manchester United’s most important player on the day spoke volumes, he is a superb young goalkeeper and his team needed him to be at his best to prevent Sunderland from taking what would have been three deserved points.

At times you felt that Sunderland could have been a little bolder to try and make the most of their dominance, both in terms of flooding the box and some slightly more aggressive substitutions from the dugout. Equally, there was a real need to tighten up after conceding nine goals in two games and Sunderland have done that over the past fortnight. There are understandable fears about ‘second-season syndrome’ but this was a performance to give you hope that Sunderland have the ability to compete against the very best at this level not just through defensive resilience, but also through genuine quality in possession. They have been an inconsistent team in the second half of the season but they have also added some really important layers to their game.

Enzo’s position switch opens up opportunities for Sunderland

Enzo Le Fée’s initial return to the left flank earlier this season was in part because of Sunderland’s issues in the wide areas but also because Le Bris and the coaching staff felt he hadn’t quite seized his chance in the early pre-season games. That seems a long time ago now.

There were strong performers all over the pitch for Sunderland but every chance they created at some stage had Le Fée at the heart of the move. Bruno Fernandes had deservedly been named the Football Writers’ Association Player of the Year in the build up to this game but here he was emphatically outshone by his opposite number. The most creative player on the pitch, Le Fée also got through a lot of defensive work. That tenacity means moving him infield doesn’t weaken Sunderland’s defensive structure, while vastly improving their chance creation. The Frenchman is Sunderland’s best player at the moment and is unlucky not to have registered another three or four assists over the last few weeks.

We’re reaching the stage of the campaign where it’s impossible not to look towards the future and as Sunderland plan behind the scenes, they are surely doing so with Le Fée in this number ten position. On this evidence, it will be a game changer for Sunderland.

Lutsharel Geertruida shines - but has it come too late?

Though Le Bris continues to insist a decision will be taken at the end of the campaign, there was little surprise that Sky Sports Germany reported on Friday that Lutsharel Geertruida will not join the Black Cats permanently this summer.

While he has featured relatively regularly this season, he hasn’t been able to make a starting position his own and ever since nearly joining Liverpool in January, it has felt increasingly inevitable that he would depart at the end of the campaign. If that does prove to be the case, then it will be a source of frustration for fans that he leaves just when he is starting to show his very best form. While he has been a solid defender pretty much from the day he arrived, in his last three games he has added a real attacking threat. Inches away from scoring a winning goal here, he has shown in his last three starts why he made such an impact at right back in Arne Slot’s title-winning Feyenoord side. Were he under a long-term contract, you’d now be looking at him as a potential key player next season and another source for optimism that this team can move forwards rather than stagnate.

Is it too optimistic to hope that another couple of strong performances in the final two weeks of the season can change the conversation?

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

Europe dream fades - but this performance will lift spirits

Given the strength of Sunderland’s performance here and the complete control they had of last weekend’s contest at the point Dan Ballard was shown a red card, it’s hard not to think of what might have been. Four extra points would have Sunderland sat eighth, firmly in contention for a European place with two games to go. While still mathematically possible, it now looks unlikely in the extreme.

A European campaign would have been a generational experience and the high point of a sensational few years following Sunderland, but there’s also no doubt that the extra games would have been a major strain on a small squad. This performance means Sunderland can look to the next campaign with optimism.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice