Phil Smith: I watched Sunderland's pre-season defeat to Leeds United and these were my key conclusions
Sunderland played the second friendly of their US tour in New Jersey on Friday
Sunderland fell to a 1-0 defeat against Leeds United in New Jersey on Friday.
Here, Phil Smith takes you through his key conclusions from the game…
A night of toil for Sunderland - but no one that should lead to panic
There’s no point pretending that this game wasn’t a bit of a tough watch for the most part. It was clear pretty much from the off that Leeds United weren’t going to press aggressively, with some passages of play offering little more than Melker Ellborg or one of his back four standing in possession waiting for movement.
That is certainly no dig at Leeds United - their approach worked well and often forced Sunderland to cough the ball up when they eventually went long. The opening goal further vindicated their approach, with Daniel Farke’s side pouncing on a slack pass from Enzo Le Fée to take the lead as Lukas Nmecha caught Ellborg off his line. Sunderland dominated possession for the vast majority of this game, aside from one spell after Le Bris made a raft of changes on the hour mark and a more experienced Leeds United XI briefly took control.
There was actually quite a lot of good in Sunderland’s build-up play, and on numerous occasions they got into decent positions without capitalising. There were multiple passages of play where the winger or the overlapping full back got into an excellent position at the byline, but the forwards crashing the box weren’t on the same wavelength and the crosses were cleared. Similarly, there were moments where Sunderland were able to open up the Leeds backline with their wingers drifting infield but a bit of indecision or poor decision making meant Farke’s side could recover. The positive is that the general foundations of Sunderland’s play were good, and so there is reason to be optimistic and believe that they will start to find their goalscoring boots as they sharpen up and players get used to each other again.
If there was one criticism it would be that like on occasions last season, Sunderland could have been a little bolder in getting more bodies into the box. It’s a delicate balance and Sunderland’s strong structure is their strength, but it’s an area of their game where they can still improve.
Minutes more important than result
Sunderland have lost the first two games of their US tour but it’s worth remembering at this point that the Black Cats lost five of their pre-season fixtures this time last year. As Le Bris pointed out after the game, he could have fielded a stronger side in phases of the game but carefully managing minutes is his priority. That meant some slightly left-field positioning with Habib Diarra playing as the midfield anchor when he came on, Timur Tutierov as the centre forward for a long spell and Simon Adingra on the right. The shape of the side was changing regularly through the second half as Le Bris methodically worked through his pre-planned subs, which meant it wasn’t really until the last ten minutes that Sunderland could settle and really apply pressure. It made for an underwhelming second half but the fast starts Sunderland have made when the serious stuff in each of the last two years suggests Le Bris’s plan is a sound one.
You could see even in defeat a number of players improving as they get minutes under their belt, with Reinildo and Nordi Mukiele both having solid games for example. Ultimately, that’s what matters.
Simon Adingra makes a positive impression on his World Cup return
It’s very difficult to imagine that Simon Adingra stays and plays a role for Sunderland this season given that his replacement is effectively already in the building in Nilson Angulo. With Chemsdine Talbi likely to get more minutes on the left flank this season, there isn’t a clear path to the first team for Adingra and he’ll want to be playing regularly. From a club perspective, it makes little sense financially to keep one of their biggest signings around when he isn’t featuring week in, week out.
Fair play to Adingra, though, for making a real positive impact on his return and in a more unfamiliar right wing role. Leeds United struggled with his movement at times, the winger often drifting infield to offer an extra player in possession. When he stayed wide he showed his quality with some good deliveries, one of which Trey Ogunsuyi nodded just wide of the post. Even if Adingra does not feature this season, it’s crucial he stays match sharp to boost his chances of a move. His attitude here was spot on and who knows, another couple of performances like this might just give Le Bris a little pause for thought.
The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.
Tarik Muharemović looks like he might well prove to be one that got away
That the former Sassuolo defender ended up at Leeds United this summer despite interest from Sunderland was a transfer that did make sense from all angles. Leeds United moved decisively to pay the bumper fee for the Bosnia international, having banked a significant sum when Pascal Struijk moved to Brighton & Hove Albion. In turn, Struijk’s departure made Leeds United’s need greater and offered the youngster a clearer route into the starting XI than he would have had at the Stadium of Light. On this evidence, you’d have to say that Leeds have signed a bit of a gem. Yes it was only one pre-season friendly but he got through his defensive work very well and made some key challenges throughout. Most impressive was his calm on the ball, playing through Sunderland’s press with relative ease at times.
You could take the positive and say that it demonstrates Sunderland’s eye for a player who would fit their system and style clearly remains very good, even if it was hard not to feel a slight tinge of regret. Sunderland’s squad is in a good place heading into the new campaign but hopefully fans will be able to enjoy a promising debut of their own in the next couple of weeks.
Your next Sunderland read: Phil Smith's Sunderland AFC player ratings vs Leeds United with four 7s in narrow defeat
