Sunderland's highest rated players this season ahead of Newcastle United derby clash
We've taken a look at Sunderland's best players this season according to WhoScored ahead of Sunday's Wear-Tyne derby.
Sunderland take on Newcastle United this Sunday in the first Wear-Tyne derby in the Premier League since March 2016.
Tension will be high at the Stadium of Light as the two arch-rivals battle it out for local bragging rights. But more than that, Sunderland are also looking to maintain a strong start to life back in the top flight that’s seen them to ninth with 23 points on the board after 15 games - one point ahead of the Magpies. Who has fuelled the Black Cats’ excellent form? We’ve taken a look at the top Sunderland players in the Premier League so far this season, according to WhoScored’s stats-backed player ratings.
Sunderland’s top players in 2025/26 so far
5. Robin Roefs
- WhoScored rating: 6.93
There was an element of controversy surrounding the signing of Robin Roefs, given the key role Anthony Patterson played in getting Sunderland promoted. However, the Dutchman has silenced any doubters with a string of fantastic performances, keeping four clean sheets so far and making 52 saves - only Martin Dubravka (56) has made more.
4. Dan Ballard
- WhoScored rating: 7.03
Dan Ballard has adjusted brilliantly to life back in the Premier League, enjoying some huge moments. Chief among them were a goal and clearance off the line in the 3-0 opening-weekend win over West Ham, not to mention netting the opener in the 2-2 draw with Arsenal in November.
3. Nordi Mukiele
- WhoScored rating: 7.08
Nordi Mukiele has proven himself vital in terms of his versatility and consistency this season, performing to a high level whether deployed at centre-back or right-back. The Frenchman has a goal and an assist to his name, while he’s first among Sunderland players for tackles (36) and interceptions (19).
2. Omar Alderete
- WhoScored rating: 7.09
Omar Alderete was one of the stars of Sunderland’s early dart out of the blocks, grabbing an assist against West Ham and scoring the winner at Nottingham Forest in September. The Paraguayan lost his place in the side for a short while, but has returned with some standout recent performances, including a WhoScored Man of the Match showing in the 1-1 draw at Liverpool - making nine clearances, one tackle and one interception, and winning two aerial duels to score 7.7.
1. Granit Xhaka
- WhoScored rating: 7.17
Granit Xhaka has been an absolute revelation at the Stadium of Light. The Swiss veteran has brought all of his Bayer Leverkusen title-winning quality and Premier League experience with Arsenal to anchor the Sunderland midfield, registering a goal and four assists so far, while sitting first among Sunderland players for passes completed (649), chances created (18) and possession recoveries (67).