Phil Smith: I watched Sunderland's crucial win at Everton and these were my key conclusions
Sunderland moved to within a point of the European qualification places with a win over Everton on Sunday
Sunderland kept their hopes of European qualification alive with a 3-1 win over Everton at the Hill Dickinson Stadium on Sunday.
Phil Smith was there reporting for The Echo and these were his key conclusions…
Sunderland fans can dare to dream once more
We’re long past the point of saying that these things don’t happen to Sunderland: a club that had for so long been down on its luck and its supporters understandably accustomed to expecting the worst has a very different DNA these days. Perhaps we shouldn’t be surprised, then, that this season has taken yet another twist. After a heavy defeat on home turf against Nottingham Forest, the season was at risk of just petering out a little. Though the race for Europe was far from over, it seemed unlikely to say the least.
To their credit, Sunderland dug in to take something back to the north east from Wolves despite playing most of the match with ten, before performing well against Manchester United without getting the full reward they deserved. That point nevertheless kept Sunderland in the hunt and though less dramatic, this afternoon evoked that famous afternoon at Preston North End where everything went the club’s way and they swept into the play-offs with a glorious exhibition of counter-attacking football.
Brentford’s late equaliser against Crystal Palace may have ever so slightly taken the edge off, but Dominic Calvert-Lewin’s late goal against Brighton meant Sunderland’s surge at Everton kept the Europa League firmly in play. 50 points, two derby wins… it has been one of the most successful campaigns in Sunderland’s modern history and a very fitting way for the club to secure its 2000th league win. Can they really finish it with a win over Chelsea and a place in Europe? This is Régis Le Bris’s Sunderland: You simply can’t rule it out.


Attacking substitutions pay off handsomely for Le Bris and Sunderland
It says much about the development of this Sunderland side that they were able to come away from home and dominate possession to the extent they did in the first half here. Whereas earlier in the season their success was about controlling the game without the ball and defending their box impressively, here they had enjoyed 70% possession at the half hour mark. Of course, having the ball counts for little if you don’t do much with it and that was the case for the Black Cats. While Le Bris’s decision to stick with the same shape following a good performance against Manchester United made sense, the decision to play Trai Hume on the right wing again looked conservative given how little defending Sunderland were actually having to do.
To his credit, the head coach moved earlier than he normally would and stuck with his decision to introduce Chemsdine Talbi despite Sunderland getting an equaliser while he was warming up. When that didn’t immediately change the flow of the game, with Everton actually going on to enjoy a strong passage of play in the immediate aftermath, he moved again. The introduction of Wilson Isidor, Chris Rigg and Habib Diarra gave Sunderland real impetus and legs at a crucial moment as the game just began to open up for the first time.
For much of the campaign, Sunderland haven’t really had the options on the bench to seize the initiative in this manner. It bodes well for next season that their squad is getting visibly stronger and that Diarra was able to draw a line under a frustrating few weeks with such an impactful cameo.
As for Rigg, there is little doubt that he is going to have a big part to play next season.
Sunderland’s form offers real hope they can avoid ‘second-season syndrome’
There’s no doubt Sunderland face a big challenge next season, they won’t catch teams off guard and they’ll have to improve their often underwhelming performance data if they’re to have any chance of replicating their current position.
Yet the perception mostly put forward by neutrals that they will labour next season now that the adrenaline surge of their promotion and summer window has worn off is increasingly struggling to withstand scrutiny.
The Premier League form table for the last ten games puts Sunderland in eighth, and for the last six games in twelfth. Young players are gaining more experience at the level, and the emergence of Enzo Le Fée in his strongest central position has done much to address the creative issues the team had in the first half of the campaign. Sunderland face a pivotal window to improve the depth of their squad and retain the players who have done so well this season, of that there is no doubt, but there are strong indications that are progressing rather than regressing as the season draws to a close.
The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.
Sunderland’s win over Everton is very good business for the club
That Sunderland have not faded away after passing 40 points and securing their Premier League status for another year isn’t just encouraging for the future; it’s very good business in a division where revenue is becoming crucial.
In the aftermath of that heavy defeat to Nottingham Forest, Sunderland were a couple of poor results away from dropping away into lower midtable. That would not have detracted from a hugely successful campaign, but it would have cost the club cash. Last season, each place in the Premier League table was worth approximately £2.6 million in additional prize money. This win means that the lowest Sunderland is 12th last season, a scenario that would not only require them to lose to Chelsea, but Everton to beat Spurs and Newcastle v Fulham not ending as a draw. For context, Crystal Palace finished 12th last season and walked away with a touch of £136 million in revenue from the Premier League.
Finish seventh or eighth, and Sunderland could put close to £10 million in additional prize money in the bank. It’s a reminder that in this division, there truly is no such thing as a dead rubber.
Your next Sunderland read: Sunderland player ratings after Everton win
