Dan Neil has joined Rangers after leaving Sunderland, but compensation rules mean no payment is expected

Sunderland are not expected to receive compensation after Dan Neil’s move to Rangers, despite the midfielder being a homegrown player and having spent his entire career on Wearside.

Neil has joined Rangers as a free agent after his Sunderland contract expired this summer. That means there is no transfer fee involved, with the 24-year-old moving on after more than 200 senior appearances for the Black Cats. The obvious question is whether Sunderland are due any kind of payment because Neil came through the Academy of Light. In this case, the key detail is his age.

Under the FA’s compensation rules, a club can usually claim a fee when an out-of-contract player is under the age of 24, has rejected an offer of re-engagement and then signs for another club in England. The FA guidance says that if a player has reached the age of 24 on or before June 30 and his contract has expired, no compensation can be claimed by the former club. It also states that no compensation is payable if the player moves abroad.

Neil is 24 and has moved to Rangers, who play in Scotland under a different association. That means the standard English domestic compensation route does not apply. There is also FIFA training compensation to consider because this is a cross-border move. FIFA’s guidance says a player’s training period runs between the ages of 12 and 23, with training compensation payable as a general rule up to the age of 23 for training up to the age of 21. Neil is already 24, so that route is not expected to create a payment either.

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

Solidarity payments are slightly different. FIFA says clubs that trained a player between the ages of 12 and 23 may be entitled to solidarity contributions when the mechanism applies. But those payments are linked to a transfer fee. Because Neil has moved as a free agent, there is no transfer fee for Sunderland to receive a percentage of.

So, in plain English, Neil being homegrown does not automatically mean Sunderland get money. Had he been younger, or sold while under contract, the situation could have been different. But because he is 24, out of contract and has moved on a free, Sunderland are not expected to receive compensation.

Your next Sunderland read - James Copley: Granit Xhaka silence fuels Sunderland betrayal fears as Chelsea transfer storm grows