Sunderland's stats-backed Premier League 2025/26 best XI: Dan Ballard leads the way

Who have been Sunderland's top performers in the Premier League this season?

Sunderland finally returned to winning ways with a 1-0 victory away at Leeds United - their first in the Premier League since the start of February.

As a result, the Black Cats have climbed back to 11th in the table, already hitting the 40-point mark after just 29 games, 12 clear of the relegation zone and just four adrift of the top seven. No matter what happens from here, it’s been a great return to life in the top-flight for Sunderland, but which players have been most responsible for it? Below, we’ve picked Regis Le Bris’ best starting line-up, based on the stats-backed player ratings from WhoScored (only players to have featured in 25%+ possible minutes have been considered).

Sunderland’s strongest 2025/26 line-up

  • GK: Robin Roefs - 6.73
  • RB: Nordi Mukiele - 7.01
  • CB: Dan Ballard - 7.02
  • CB: Omar Alderete - 6.99
  • LB: Reinildo Mandava - 6.72
  • CM: Granit Xhaka - 7.01
  • CM: Noah Sadiki - 6.56
  • RW: Chemsdine Talbi - 6.34
  • CAM: Habib Diarra - 6.46
  • LW: Enzo Le Fee - 6.69
  • ST: Brian Brobbey - 6.43

There are a few very predictable names in the above side, not least instrumental midfielder Granit Xhaka, who has been one of the league’s signings of the season so far. Robin Roefs has also been crucial to Sunderland’s excellent defensive record with a string of incredible saves, but the Dutchman will be well aware that he cannot let performances drop once he returns from injury after Melker Ellborg scored 7.23 on his debut against Leeds - making four saves to preserve a clean sheet. Dan Ballard has been solid in recent games, elevating himself to a starting spot alongside Omar Alderete, with Nordi Mukiele edging out Trai Hume at right-back, despite also featuring heavily through the middle.

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

Things are a little more difficult up-front, with Le Bris’ side very much relying on their solidity. However, Enzo Le Fee has a team-high eight direct goal involvements (4g/4a), while Brian Brobbey is Sunderland’s top goalscorer with five goals in 22 appearances, only 13 of which have come from the start. Habib Diarra has scored two goals in his last six league games, plus another in the FA Cup during that time, and he’ll hope this is the start of a run of form that’ll boost his 6.46 rating.

Among the notable players missing out are Lutsharel Geertruida and Wilson Isidor on 6.37 and 6.31, respectively, as well as the aforementioned Hume on 6.65. Up next for Sunderland is an FA Cup tie away at Port Vale on Sunday, before they look to move into the Premier League top half when hosting Brighton next week.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice