Phil Smith: I watched Sunderland’s draw at Aston Villa and these were my key conclusions
Sunderland made it two clean sheets from two at Villa Park on Saturday
Sunderland battled to a hard-fought point against Aston Villa on Saturday afternoon.
Phil Smith was there reporting for The Echo and these were his key conclusions…
Away end response reflects step in the right direction
This is not a game that will live long in the memory and it would be pointless to pretend otherwise. Sunderland’s last trip to Villa Park was a madcap game with an extraordinary finish destined to be repeated on future editions of Premier League Years; this was prime fodder for the last slot on Match of the Day.
At times, Sunderland’s cautious approach will have tested the travelling support who watched their side spend long spells near their own box and register only a handful of shots on target. There was less entertainment on show than there had been at Man City earlier in the season, for example, but the reception to the 0-0 draw at the final whistle reflected where Sunderland are at and an understanding of how they are going to get out of it.
The players received a very generous ovation as they headed over to suit their fans, deserved for their application, concentration and togetherness in the game.
The feeling was very different to that at the final whistle at Coventry City and Bournemouth, when Sunderland had simply not turned up and got the result they deserved. Across the board there felt like a recognition here that Sunderland had to show they were up for the fight ahead and they did that. Another small step in the right direction.
It’s fair to feel a bit of disappointment that Sunderland aren’t right now able to get on the front foot and make the running as they did at Brentford early in the season, but the situation was fast becoming critical and the response from head coach and players has been a sensible and solid one.
Black Friday deal: get a whole year of the Sunderland Echo for just £12. That's £1 a month, saving over 75% on the usual £49.99 a year. New subscribers only. Offer ends Thursday 3 December.
Le Bris has a platform to build on
It has been a very, very rare occasion this season when Le Bris has not been forced to reshuffle his back four this season whether due to injury, suspension or an alarming dip in form.
The question he asked his players ahead of this game was, ‘Can you repeat what you did against Chelsea?’ It’s no coincidence that with the same personnel in defence, they did. Nordi Mukiele was again excellent, underlining his status as perhaps Sunderland’s most important player at the moment. Thomas Meunier was very good again, and that pair look absolutely crucial to digging Sunderland out of this hole. After a tricky start to the season, Robin Roefs is also beginning to find some welcome consistency with more stability in front of him.
The Sunderland head coach made a conscious decision to shift style in order to tighten up and in the last two games he has found some green shoots to build from.
Brian Brobbey worry isn’t going away anytime soon
Even if there were positives than negatives on the day, worries about Sunderland’s attacking output and particularly in the absence of Brian Brobbey were not eased by this performance.
Though Sunderland were consciously looking to avoid going long early on, Aston Villa’s strong structure and pressing meant that it was inevitable as the game went on. Sunderland badly lacked a focal point in these moments and especially when Wilson Isidor began to tire in the second half.
The centre forward had a difficult game here, which you perhaps expect given how little support there was around him and his international commitments in the week. There’s an argument that Sunderland need to do more to spring him behind early where his pace can make a difference, but equally there are times when the 26-year-old seems to be caught on his heels a little and especially when you compare the way Nicolas Jackson moved off the shoulder of the Sunderland centre halves in the first half here. Regardless, it’s a worry that Sunderland are in a position where they’re bringing on a winger to play up front in the latter stages of the game in Brobbey’s absence. If Juan Riquelme Angulo understandably needs a longer adaptation process than initially hoped or anticipated, then Sunderland might have to do something in this position in the January window.
Join the Echo’s WhatsApp SAFC Channel for the latest news, team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join.
Chemsdine Talbi makes the left-wing position his to lose for now
It was almost a magic moment to end the game, a superb solo run and almost an audacious finish into the far corner to snatch three points. No doubt Talbi will be feeling a little bit of frustration after this game, especially as he’d nearly burst through minutes before only to be denied by a superb covering challenge from Taylor Harwood-Bellis.
This was in its own a way a big positive for Sunderland, though. Talbi had dug in for much of the game and offered support to Reinildo, but still had the speed and energy late on to offer his side a threat.
Talbi has made a very solid return to the starting XI in the last two games, and the need for a bit of consistency and stability right across the pitch means he is now surely set for a bit of a run in the Premier League. If he keeps working as he did here off the ball, his ability to pop up with a goal makes him hard to leave out. It has been an odd six months or so for Talbi and Sunderland and Malick Fofana’s struggle to make an impact is an issue for the Black Cats, but this was a definite positive from the game.
