In his time at the Academy of Light, the former Birmingham City man has overseen a radical overhaul of the club’s playing squad with the Wearsiders focusing on their academy, and buying young players to be nurtured and blooded in the first team.
It is a strategy that has produced results, with Speakman providing a squad that Alex Neil managed to brilliantly turn into promotion winners following Lee Johnson’s under-achievement.
However, with any recruitment strategy, there are pros and cons. Speakman has been criticised in some quarters for not providing Sunderland with enough depth, as evidenced by the injuries to Ross Stewart and the recall of Ellis Simms which left Tony Mowbray without any senior strikers for large parts of last season.
Here, though, we drill down into every signing sanctioned by Speakman since his arrival at the club and rate them from one to ten.
Note that we don’t include the signings of Mason Burstow, Nazariy Rusyn, Jenson Seelt, Eliezer Mayenda, Timothee Pembele and Adil Aouchiche as they haven’t played for the club as of yet and we haven’t included youth team signings like Timur Tuterov.

1. Carl Winchester
Winchester was a solid pick-up from Forest Green Rovers and another player well known to Johnson. Nicknamed “Winniesta” by supporters, he played with heart and versatility, filling roles in midfield, right-back and even at centre-half. The sort of dependable pro every promotion-winning squad needs. 7/10 Photo: Alex Burstow

2. Jordan Jones
Showed flashes of real quality but lacked consistency and ultimately couldn’t help Sunderland over the promotion line during his six-month loan. The logic behind the move made sense, yet it didn’t quite come together on the pitch. 5/10 Photo: Bryn Lennon

3. Jake Vokins
Vokins arrived to provide depth at left-back but his progress was hampered by injury and covid-related absences. The thinking was clear – young, hungry and talented – but circumstances limited him to just four league outings. 2/10 Photo: Naomi Baker

4. Callum Doyle
It’s easy to forget how impressive Callum Doyle was in his first season on Wearside. Still a teenager, he handled the physical demands admirably and played a part in Sunderland’s promotion. His influence waned late in the campaign, but his quality shone through. 8/10 Photo: Alex Burstow


