James Copley: Régis Le Bris weighing up huge derby decisions ahead of Newcastle United clash
Sunderland prepare for a fiery Wear-Tyne derby with big decisions to make on shape, striker choice and a midfield test of character
There are Premier League matches, and then there is Sunderland vs Newcastle. The tone changes. The air tightens. This one will be lived rather than watched.
And heading into Sunday, Régis Le Bris stands at an interesting crossroads. He has two strikers with contrasting traits, multiple shapes that have worked in different ways, and a set-piece edge that could be a weapon – if Sunderland can outmanoeuvre the giant frames in black and white.
Isidor or Brobbey? A derby call loaded with narrative
The first big decision sits up front. Wilson Isidor has four goals in 15 league games. Brian Brobbey has two goals and one assist in 10, with significantly fewer minutes than Isidor. For much of the season, Sunderland have rotated them on what has become, unofficially, a 60-30 system – one starts, the other finishes.
Isidor carries recent wounds. The chance at Anfield lingers in the collective memory: he rounds Alisson brilliantly, only for Federico Chiesa to slide back and clear what felt like destiny. It is easy to judge in slow motion. In real time, it was instinct, courage and inches. At the Etihad, he engineered a chance himself through pressing, but shot straight at Donnarumma. Small margins, two moments, no goals. Football can be cruel in its simplicity.
Brobbey, meanwhile, has scored more recently. He struck against Arsenal. He won Sunderland three points against Bournemouth. He brings muscle, hold-up play, a bruising presence late in games when legs sag, and concentration loosens. Isidor stretches defenders and runs behind. Brobbey pins them and wears them down. One stresses space, the other stresses bodies. So what does Le Bris want the game to look like? If he wants chaos, depth and transition, Isidor feels the pick. If he wants control, link play, and a reference point against a physically imposing defence, Brobbey has the edge. The truth is, either choice will be brave. That is the nature of derbies.
Midfield battle: finesse, fire and a real measuring stick for Sunderland
If the striker debate is intriguing, the midfield clash might define the entire afternoon. Newcastle’s trio of Bruno Guimaraes, Sandro Tonali and Joelinton, when in rhythm, are right up there with the most complete midfields in the Premier League. They are technical, combative, athletic and relentless. They can pass between lines, break play, carry through pressure and hurt you in transition. Physically, they are a handful. Technically, they are elegant. Mentally, they are hardened.
The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.
For Sunderland, this is an exam. A test of where they stand at Premier League level, not in theory but in the furnace of real pressure. Noah Sadiki and Enzo Le Feé have been two of the most transformative players under Régis Le Bris. Sadiki covers grass with incredible speed, presses with menace and has grown with every game. Le Feé is best at linking phases, rotating possession, and slipping passes into pockets. If they start together, this may be the biggest midfield they have faced yet, and we will learn a lot about where they are right now.
And then there is Granit Xhaka. The heartbeat. The organiser. The conductor. He dictates tempo, drags teammates into position, slows the right moments and accelerates the wrong ones for the opponent. In a game where temperature runs hot, Xhaka’s experience might be the valve that keeps Sunderland playing with clarity rather than chaos.
Derbies are often decided not by tactics alone but by who controls the middle. Who wins second balls. Who turns 50-50s into 60-40s. Who walks away as leader rather than passenger. If Sunderland come out on top in the engine room, they give themselves a real shot. If Newcastle dominate that space, the afternoon becomes long. Midfield will not just be a battleground. It might be the battleground.
Shape, structure and the balance between security and ambition
Sunderland’s recent tactical flexibility has been a strength. Across the past five matches, we have seen 5-4-1, 4-4-1-1 and 4-3-3. The back five gave structure at Stamford Bridge and resilience against Arsenal at the Stadium of Light. But at home to Everton, it blunted creativity. Away at Manchester City, it survived until elite finishing took the game away.
At the Stadium of Light against Newcastle United, the logic leans towards four at the back. A 4-3-3 in possession that shifts to 4-4-1-1 off the ball would suit Sunderland’s best technicians and give Le Bris freedom to push full-backs on. It is also the best system for Le Fee to best display his attacking instincts .
Set pieces could be decisive – if Sunderland can handle Newcastle’s height
One of the most discussed strengths of this Sunderland side is set-pieces. Corners and long throws have become organised, threatening, purposeful. Movement is choreographed. First contacts are increasing. Second-ball aggression is growing. It is a genuine weapon.
But Newcastle have the enormous Dan Burn and Nick Woltemade for Sunderland to contend with. Sunderland will not win aerial battles by brute force alone. and face a very different challenge when defending set-pieces against Newcastle. They will need timing, screens, blocks, delayed runs and clever delivery. It could become one of the defining battlegrounds of the derby. Whoever makes the most of this area of the game will surely give themselves a huge leg up on Sunday. But this match will not be decided purely on formation boards.
The stakes are emotional as much as tactical
This is one of those weeks where every detail feels bigger. The striker decision. The shape. The rhythm of the midfield. When to press and when to hold. When to roll the ball and when to launch it. Derby games are played in tactics, but won in courage. And that is the point. Sunderland are not coming into this tentatively.
They have grown. They have scars and belief in equal measure. They have found ways to hurt elite sides but have also suffered some setbacks to learn from, particularly against Manchester United and Manchester City. They have legs, creativity and enough steel to trouble anyone. They also have flaws that Newcastle will try to pull at. It will come down to who leans into the moment rather than away from it. The margins might be tiny. The consequences could be enormous. Sunday will not be quiet.
Your next Sunderland read: 'Refocus' – Granit Xhaka issues clear message to Sunderland fans ahead of Newcastle United game