George Lapslie’s second half header saw the Black Cats knocked out at the first round stage for the second year running as the fourth tier side claimed their first win of the season.
So did any players emerge with credit from the clash?
Scroll down and click through the pages as Phil Smith dishes out his merit marks:
9. Chris Maguire
Set-piece delivery was mixed and had very little influence from open play in a contest that you would have expected him to dictate from the off. Looked off the pace and unsurprisingly replaced midway through the second half. 4 Photo: Frank Reid
10. Will Grigg
An excellent early touch nearly produced an assist for Graham, but was an increasingly peripheral figure as the game progressed. Barely registered an effort on goal. 5 Photo: Frank Reid
11. Danny Graham
Was unfortunate to hit the post with his first effort of the game, an instinctive first-time effort that left the goalkeeper helpless. The second effort was a gilt-edged opening that he had to score, turning a cross onto the bar from two yards out at most. Some good touches but was left to rue that miss when withdrawn after the hour. 5 Photo: Frank Reid
12. Elliot Embleton
One or two clever touches and a wonderful cross in a bright cameo. His return was one of the few positives. 6 Photo: FRANK REID