

Phil Smith's Sunderland AFC player ratings: Who shone and struggled in Hull City cup clash?
Despite dominating the game for large spells, the Black Cats failed to find the elusive breakthrough which meant the first round tie headed to penalties.
And after Will Grigg missed his spot kick, Hull took advantage to claim progression.
So who impressed for the Black Cats? Scroll down to see Phil Smith’s ratings from the game...
So who impressed for the Black Cats? Scroll down to see Phil Smith’s ratings from the game...

5. Luke O'Nien
Perhaps should have done better with a free header early on. Got forward regularly and was unlucky not to yield an assist when Grigg was flagged offside when turning home his good low cross. 6 Photo: FRANK REID 2019

6. Denver Hume
Delivered some excellent crosses and to that end was unlucky not to play a part in a goal. Also went close with a good header after the break and was encouragingly tenacious in his defensive work, thundering into a couple of 50-50 challenges. 7 Photo: FRANK REID 2020

7. George Dobson
Sat a little deeper than usual and was good in the opening exchanges, covering ground and keeping the ball moving. A little quieter in the second half as Hull recovered from their remarkably sluggish start. 6 Photo: FRANK REID 2020

8. Max Power
Parkinson sprung a surprise by releasing Power to play higher than usual. He has so often been the holding midfielder but had far greater licence here and in the first half in particular, looked to relish it. Scored a good penalty. 7 Photo: Frank Reid